Okay, we still have one more tie to break. This poll will expire at midnight.
#11 Carlos Silva Throws 11-Hit Shutout
Against the Angels, Silva allowed a baserunner in every inning, including 11 hits, 2 walks, and 1 error. He induced four ground-ball double plays and two line out double plays. When Silva's magic was working it was delightful.
#11 Francisco Liriano Outduels Roger Clemens
As has been discussed, this was one of the seasons where Clemens joined half-way through the season to much fanfare. Liriano was good, not great. And Clemens was also good (and he had a fantastic season just like F-Bomb), not great. But this was about the narrative.
Liriano had a couple of 8-inning, 12-strikeout games in 2006 and some more dominating performances, but this game was probably the most memorable.
The Better Moment
- Liriano Outduels Clemens (67%, 6 Votes)
- Silva Tosses 11-Hit Shutout (33%, 3 Votes)
Total Voters: 9