One man’s opinion of the top300 Twins ever

October 12, 2012 Nate Tubbs Rules 27 Comments

I stole most of the idea from when Gleeman started his top40 list years ago (still unfinished right?) The below quote is his, and the rest is an exerpt from a book I put together 2 years ago. Some of it is outdated, but I've updated the list and stats through 2012 (or as much as I could given that Baseball prospectus and b-ref keeps changing their WAR, WARP, VORP stats)

“The rankings only include time spent playing for the Minnesota Twins. In other words, David Ortiz doesn't get credit for turning into one of the best players in baseball after joining the Red Sox and Paul Molitor doesn't get credit for being one of the best players in baseball for the Brewers and Blue Jays. The Twins began playing on April 11, 1961, and that's when these rankings start as well.”

I used a variety of factors, as Gleeman did, including longevity and peak value (although looking at his list and comments he probably gave a little more weight to longevity than I did). Longevity included how many years the player was a Twin as well as how many plate appearances or innings pitched that player had in those years. For peak value, I looked at their stats, honors, and awards in their best seasons, as well as how they compared to their teammates. Did they lead their team in OPS or home runs or ERA for starters or WPA? If so, that got some bonus points. I factored in postseason heroics, awards (gold gloves, silver sluggers, MVPs, Cy Youngs), statistical achievements (batting titles, home run leaders, ERA champs, etc), and honors (all star appearances), and unlike Gleeman I looked at team success as well. If you were the #1 starter on a division winning champ, that gave you more points than the #1 starter on a cellar dweller. I looked at some of the advanced stats like WPA, WAR (as calculated by baseball.projection.com and used at baseball-reference.com), WARP3 and VORP (as calculated by Baseball Prospectus), and Win Shares (as calculated by Bill James). For hitters, I also looked at OPS and the old school triple crown statistics like batting average, home runs, stolen bases, and RBI (and not only where you finished within the AL in any given year, but where you appear on the top25 lists amongst all Twins in the last 50 years). For pitchers I looked at strikeouts, innings pitched, win/loss percentage, ERA as well as ERA). If there was a metric that was used for all 50 years of Twins history, I tried to incorporate it. I tended to give more credit to guys who were starters instead of part time/platoon players, more credit to position players over pitchers (just slightly, but probably unfairly) and starters over relievers (and closers over middle relievers). There’s no formula to my magic, just looking at a lot of factors and in the end going with the gut in all tie-breakers. Up in the top10 I’m looking at All star appearances, Cy Young and MVP votes, batting average or ERA titles or top10 finishes, etc, and placement in the top25 hitting and pitching lists in Twins history as well. In the middle 100s, it’s more about who started a few more years or had 2 good seasons rather than 1 with possibly an occasional all-star berth or top10 finish in SB or strikeouts. Once you’re in the latter half of the 200s there are none of those on anyone’s resume, so its basically just looking at peak season in OPS+ or ERA+, WAR, Win Shares, and who started the most years, had the most at bats, or pitched the most innings. What the player did as a coach, manager, or broadcaster is not taken into consideration for this list, so Tom Kelly or Billy Gardner weren’t able to make the top 300 since they were poor players and Frank Quilici and Billy Martin didn’t improve their status due to their managing careers.

Rk	Player	Years	Date Range	AB/IP	YrS	ERA+ or OPS+	HR/W	ERA or AVG	VORP	WAR	WARP3	WS	AS	Awards	Top 10 statistical finishes
1	Harmon Killebrew	14	1961-1974	6593	9	148	475	0.26	532.3	54.9	46.6	318	10	MVP: 11,3,4,10,15,4,2,1,3,21	AVG: 5 OPS: 4,2,2,4,2,3,2,4,10,10 R: 10,7,3,8,2,4,8 HR: 3,1,1,1,8,2,1,1,2,5,3 RBI: 6,1,3,3,2,2,1,4,1
2	Kirby Puckett	12	1984-1995	7244	12	124	207	0.318	504.1	45	43.4	281	10	6 GG, 6 SS, MVP: 21,6,3,3,7,7,2,7,21, ALCS MVP	AVG: 3,4,2,1,10,8,2 OPS 4,6,8 R: 2,5,4 HR: 6, RBI: 2,6,1
3	Rod Carew	12	1967-1978	6235	11	137	74	0.334	603.8	62.7	56.5	282	12	ROY, MVP: 10,14,4,7,9,5,1,11	AVG: 6,1,5,1,1,1,1,3,1,1 OPS: 4,4,3,2,1 R: 4,2,5,7,2,1 SB: 4,2,4,6
4	Tony Oliva	15	1962-1976	6301	11	131	220	0.304	372.3	42.4	36.4	245	8	ROY, 1 GG, MVP: 4,2,6,19,19,15,2,10	AVG: 1,1,2,8,3,3,3,1 OPS: 5,3,6,6,7,2 R: 1,2,2,9,8 HR: 6 RBI: 9,3,10,5,7,5 SB: 6
5	Joe Mauer	9	2004-2012	3933	7	135	94	0.323	385.3	44.5	45.2	207	5	3 GG, 4 SS, MVP: 6,4,1,8	AVG: 1,1,1,3,4 OPS 7,1,10
6	Kent Hrbek	14	1981-1994	6192	13	128	293	0.282	397.1	35.4	38.6	230	1	MVP: 2, 16	AVG: 7,6 OPS: 5,8,7,7 HR: 3,10,10 RBI: 7
7	Johan Santana	8	2000-2007	1308	4	141	93	3.22	388.9	32.4	33.2	123	3	1 GG, CY: 7,1,3,1, 5, MVP: 6,7	ERA: 1,2,1,7 W: 2,5,1 IP: 2,2,1,6 K: 8,1,1,1,2
8	Jim Kaat	13	1961-1973	2959	13	112	189	3.28	313.2	32.1	34.5	185	2	12 GG, MVP: 5,20	ERA: 6,6 W: 6,8,3,1,6 IP: 2,10,4,1,4 K: 4,10,2,6
9	Bert Blyleven	11	1970-1988	2567	10	119	149	3.28	445.9	44.8	48.4	178	1	CY: 7,3, MVP: 26	ERA: 5,2,4,6,5 W: 7,5,6 IP: 9,5,4,7,1,4 K: 4,4,2,2,2,1,4,8
10	Frank Viola	8	1982-1989	1773	8	111	112	3.86	278.3	24.5	27.7	117	1	CY: 6,6,1, MVP: 10, WS MVP	ERA: 10,2,3 W: 4,3,9,8,1 IP: 5,8,9,10,6 K: 8,8,7,3
11	Bob Allison	10	1961-1970	3926	7	130	211	0.254	197.3	30.9	24	169	2	MVP: 15,23	OPS: 6,1,3,9,10 R: 3,1,9 HR: 7,8,3,6,9,7,8 RBI: 7,7,4
12	Brad Radke	12	1995-2006	2451	12	113	148	4.22	491.3	41	36.8	159	1	CY: 3, MVP 25	ERA: 4,4 W: 2 IP: 8,4,6,4,8,5 K: 7
13	Chuck Knoblauch	7	1991-1997	3939	7	114	43	0.304	339.7	35.4	34.6	161	4	ROY, 1 GG, 2 SS, MVP: 20,17,16	AVG: 2,4 R: 4,8,8,2,3 SB: 9,4,4,4,2
14	Justin Morneau	10	2003-2012	4254	7	123	204	0.28	214.4	20.9	20.2	143	4	2 SS, MVP: 1, 20, 2	AVG: 7 OPS: 8 HR: 5 RBI: 2,9,2
15	Jim Perry	10	1963-1972	1883	8	113	128	3.15	245.3	23.1	26.5	125	2	CY: 3, 1, MVP: 9,9	ERA: 8,4,8,8 W: 3,1 IP: 8,5 K: 10
16	Torii Hunter	11	1997-2007	4492	8	104	192	0.271	180.2	16.8	18.9	137	2	7 GG, MVP: 21,6,21,15	HR: 7 RBI: 10 SB: 9,8,9
17	Earl Battey	7	1961-1967	2762	6	109	76	0.278	137	15.5	17.6	114	4	2 GG, MVP: 7,10	AVG: 6,10 OPS: 9 HR: 9 RBI: 9
18	Gary Gaetti	10	1981-1990	4990	9	99	201	0.256	132.7	23.8	25.3	146	2	4 GG, ALCS MVP, MVP: 16,10,22	OPS: 8,8 HR: 3,4 RBI: 5,7
19	Zoilo Versalles	7	1961-1967	4148	7	88	86	0.252	130.1	14.8	15.8	119	2	2 GG, MVP: 21, 1	R: 4,1 SB: 8,7,3
20	Joe Nathan	7	2004-2011	463	6	204	24	2.16	189.4	19.8	34.5	95	4	CY: 4,5, MVP: 12,18	SAVES: 3,3,6,6,4,2
21	Rick Aguilera	11	1989-1999	694	9	130	40	3.5	164.6	16.1	26.3	101	3	MVP: 18	SAVES: 6,3,2,6,3,3,9,5
22	Camilo Pascual	6	1961-1966	1285	6	116	88	3.31	196.4	17.6	18.9	87	3	MVP: 15,12	ERA: 10,3 W: 6,2,2 IP: 5,4,8,4 K: 1,1,1,2
23	Shane Mack	5	1990-1994	2161	5	130	67	0.309	166.2	18.5	22.4	92	0		AVG: 5,7 OPS 9,8 R: 7
24	Roy Smalley	10	1976-1987	3997	9	104	110	0.262	231.2	18.3	23.1	128	1	MVP: 16
25	Jack Morris	1	1991-1991	246	1	125	18	3.43	45.4	4.1	3.7	18	1	WS MVP, CY: 4	W: 4, IP: 3 K: 10
26	Cesar Tovar	8	1965-1972	4142	5	102	38	0.281	123	25.9	13.8	142	0	MVP: 7,23,17,18,24	AVG: 4 R: 3,3,7,2,2,5 SB: 10,6,3,3,6,7
27	Mike Cuddyer	11	2001-2011	4072	6	111	141	0.272	151.5	10.5	14.6	117	1	MVP: 21	HR: 10
28	Corey Koskie	7	1998-2004	2788	6	115	101	0.28	175.9	21.1	22.3	108	0	MVP: 25
29	Tom Brunansky	7	1982-1988	3313	6	109	163	0.25	92.3	14.6	8.4	98	1		HR: 8,6,9
30	Brian Harper	6	1988-1993	2503	5	110	48	0.306	141.9	12.3	13.4	75	0		AVG: 9
31	Larry Hisle	5	1973-1977	2437	4	127	87	0.286	131.5	17.5	16.1	89	1	MVP: 12	OPS: 10 R: 10 HR: 10 RBI: 4,1
32	Dave Goltz	8	1972-1979	1638	6	112	96	3.48	228.8	23.5	24.9	104	0	CY: 6	ERA: 8,5 W: 1 IP: 2,7 K: 6,8
33	Eddie Guardado	12	1993-2008	705	3	105	37	4.55	132.1	8.4	14.4	72	2	MVP: 15	SAVES 1,2
34	Greg Gagne	10	1983-1992	3386	8	83	69	0.249	86.1	15.1	8.6	88	0
35	Kevin Tapani	7	1989-1995	1171	6	108	75	4.06	189.4	17.5	20	74	0	CY: 7	ERA: 7 W: 10,10,10 IP: 5
36	Jimmie Hall	4	1963-1966	1885	4	124	98	0.269	100.5	15.5	9.9	76	2	MVP: 13	AVG: 8 OPS: 6 R: 7,9 HR: 4 RBI: 6 SB: 10
37	Jacque Jones	7	1999-2005	3492	6	101	132	0.279	72.9	9.2	8.8	98	0
38	Rich Rollins	8	1961-1968	3048	5	101	71	0.272	95	12	3	83	1	MVP: 8,21	AVG: 10,3 R: 7 RBI: 9
39	Mudcat Grant	4	1964-1967	780	4	107	50	3.35	74	5.2	5	44	1	MVP: 6	W: 1 IP: 3,7
40	Matt Lawton	7	1995-2001	2672	5	107	72	0.277	96.3	9.3	9.1	87	1
41	Scott Erickson	6	1990-1995	979	5	104	61	4.22	122.7	11.9	14.9	56	1	CY: 2, MVP: 17	W: 1
42	Dave Boswell	7	1964-1970	1036	5	101	67	3.49	111.9	10.4	11	61	0		W: 10,3 IP: 9 K: 8,7,4
43	Al Worthington	6	1964-1969	473	5	134	37	2.62	65.2	6.7	13.7	62	0		SAVES 7,6,6,5,1
44	Dan Gladden	5	1987-1991	2470	5	90	38	0.268	26.1	4.1	5.9	57	0
45	Butch Wynegar	7	1976-1982	2746	5	89	37	0.254	42.4	14	9.6	82	2	MVP: 28
46	Chili Davis	2	1991-1992	978	2	135	41	0.282	69.1	5.5	7.7	36	0	MVP: 14	OPS: 7 HR: 8
47	Randy Bush	12	1982-1993	3045	5	102	96	0.251	63.5	1.2	3.2	76	0
48	Steve Braun	6	1971-1976	2429	3	116	35	0.284	107.3	14.7	13.3	86	0
49	Dean Chance	3	1967-1969	664	3	126	41	2.67	78.3	8.7	11.1	46	1	MVP: 13	ERA: 9 W: 3,8 IP: 1,2 K: 3,4
50	Lyman Bostock	3	1975-1977	1436	3	127	18	0.318	89.6	10.9	9	54	0	MVP: 27	AVG: 4,2 R: 4
51	Jason Kubel	7	2004-2011	2559	4	112	104	0.271	94.6	6.1	8.8	73	0	MVP: 24	RBI: 8
52	Jeff Reardon	3	1987-1989	226	3	116	15	3.7	45.8	4.3	7.4	36	1	CY: 8, MVP: 11,15	SAVES: 2,2,7
53	Leo Cardenas	3	1969-1971	1720	3	98	39	0.263	92.7	10.9	15.3	64	1	MVP: 12,21
54	Denard Span	5	2008-2012	2354	4	104	23	0.284	96.4	14.6	14.8	78	0		AVG: 9
55	Paul Molitor	3	1996-1998	1700	3	103	23	0.312	63.5	4.9	2.6	41	0	1 SS, MVP: 13	AVG: 3
56	Ron Perranoski	4	1968-1971	359	2	120	25	3	31.5	2.9	7.3	41	0	CY: 7, MVP: 13,12	SAVES 1,1
57	Scott Baker	7	2005-2011	958	5	102	63	4.15	153.3	14.9	12.8	56	0		ERA: 8 W: 10
58	Marty Cordova	5	1995-1999	2322	5	103	79	0.277	75.2	4.5	10.7	58	0	ROY
59	Eric Milton	6	1998-2003	987	5	101	57	4.76	147	13.4	9.3	55	1		K: 9,10
60	Bill Campbell	4	1973-1976	460	2	121	32	3.13	70	7.6	11.7	45	0	CY: 7, MVP: 8	W: 8 SAVES: 3,3
61	Don Mincher	6	1961-1966	1511	2	125	90	0.244	80.1	8.8	5.1	57	0
62	Jerry Koosman	3	1979-1981	601	3	115	39	3.77	102.2	10.6	11.9	44	0	CY: 6	ERA: 8 W: 3,10 IP: 4 K: 5,7
63	A.J. Pierzynski	6	1998-2003	1428	3	105	26	0.301	79	7.9	9.8	58	1		AVG: 8
64	John Castino	6	1979-1984	2320	5	96	41	0.278	71.2	13	7.1	70	0	ROY
65	Dan Ford	4	1975-1978	1999	4	114	57	0.272	67.9	6.4	2.2	57	0		R: 10 HR: 9
66	LaTroy Hawkins	9	1995-2003	819	5	95	44	5.05	85.1	6.2	7.1	50	0		SAVES: 8
67	Allan Anderson	6	1986-1991	818	4	102	49	4.11	75.6	7.8	9.4	43	0		ERA 1 W 8,6
68	Geoff Zahn	4	1977-1980	852	4	106	53	3.9	97.1	8.7	10.8	50	0		ERA: 9,10
69	Mike Marshall	3	1978-1980	274	2	141	21	2.99	65.4	6.7	12.4	37	0	CY: 7, 5, MVP: 11	SAVES: 4,1
70	Gary Ward	5	1979-1983	1543	3	115	51	0.285	70.9	9.2	5.1	48	1	MVP: 32
71	Shannon Stewart	4	2003-2006	1373	1	102	29	0.294	34.1	2.8	1.9	39	0	MVP: 4	AVG: 10
72	Doug Mientkiewicz	7	1998-2004	2147	5	103	43	0.275	46.5	3.7	4.3	62	0	1 GG, MVP: 14
73	Rich Reese	10	1964-1973	1918	4	99	50	0.26	19.9	3.8	-0.8	52	0	MVP: 29
74	Ron Coomer	6	1995-2000	2397	2	88	77	0.278	13.8	1.6	1	44	1
75	Mickey Hatcher	6	1981-1986	2366	3	89	26	0.284	26.4	2.5	1.1	47	0
76	Bobby Darwin	4	1972-1975	1817	3	107	70	0.257	37.1	3	-0.5	46	0		HR: 7,4 RBI: 6,5
77	Tim Laudner	9	1981-1989	2038	3	84	77	0.225	23.2	2.8	0.7	41	1
78	Gene Larkin	7	1987-1993	2321	2	98	32	0.266	46	1.8	2.3	54	0
79	Francisco Liriano	7	2005-2012	783	5	97	50	4.33	110.8	8.7	11.1	42	1	CY: 11	K: 5
80	Carlos Silva	4	2004-2007	773	4	102	47	4.42	104.4	7.6	6.2	42	0		ERA 5, W: 8
81	Joe Mays	6	1999-2005	946	6	98	48	4.85	121.2	8.3	7.5	44	1		ERA: 3 W: 6 IP: 3
82	Cristian Guzman	6	1999-2004	3277	6	76	39	0.266	31.8	3.9	2.7	76	1	MVP: 16	SB: 7
83	Mike Smithson	4	1984-1987	816	4	97	47	4.46	76.7	4.1	7.5	44	0		IP: 7,6 K: 10
84	Jim Merritt	4	1965-1968	686	2	112	37	3.03	74.2	8.7	10.3	44	0		ERA: 5 K: 9
85	Juan Berenguer	4	1987-1990	418	0	116	33	3.7	74.7	4	8.4	35	0
86	Juan Rincon	8	2001-2008	441	0	122	30	3.69	87.4	5.3	8	38	0
87	Delmon Young	4	2008-2011	1845	3	103	47	0.287	45.2	0.4	2.8	48	0	MVP: 10	RBI: 5
88	David Ortiz	6	1997-2002	1477	4	107	58	0.266	46.5	2.2	1.9	37	0
89	Dick Stigman	4	1962-1965	643	3	101	37	3.69	78.1	4.6	3.9	33	0		W: 10 K: 3
90	Jack Kralick	3	1961-1963	510	2	111	26	3.74	79.1	6.7	6.9	31	0		IP: 8,7
91	Doug Corbett	3	1980-1982	246	2	170	10	2.49	69	8.2	11.4	37	1		SAVES: 6,4
92	Kyle Lohse	6	2001-2006	908	5	93	51	4.88	91.2	5.1	4.2	40	0
93	Josh Willingham	1	2012-2012	519	1	144	35	0.26	37.2	2.9	4.5	22	0		HR: 7, OPS: 8, RBI: 3
94	Ken Landreaux	2	1979-1980	1048	2	105	22	0.294	40	1.2	-1.8	29	1
95	Carl Pavano	4	2009-2012	579	2	95	33	4.32	69	6.8	7.8	28	0		W: 7, IP: 6
96	Ted Uhlaender	5	1965-1969	1846	4	87	23	0.262	6.3	2.6	-4.9	50	0	MVP: 27	AVG: 5
97	Lenny Green	4	1961-1964	1514	2	98	27	0.268	30.8	5.4	0.8	48	0		R: 6 SB: 7
98	Vic Power	3	1962-1964	1197	2	89	26	0.278	20	1.4	-0.2	25	0	2 GG, MVP: 21
99	Mike Trombley	9	1992-2002	645	2	104	30	4.53	101.3	6.5	9.3	45	0
100	Matt Guerrier	7	2004-2010	472	0	129	19	3.38	116.3	6.8	8.9	40	0
101	Pat Meares	6	1993-1998	2464	6	76	41	0.265	44.6	5.7	1.6	49	0
102	Pedro Munoz	6	1990-1995	1587	3	101	61	0.275	36.7	-1.7	2.3	37	0
103	Mark Guthrie	7	1989-1995	489	2	103	29	4.19	54.6	4.2	6.3	30	0
104	Tom Johnson	5	1974-1978	273	1	116	23	3.39	40	2.4	6	24	0	MVP: 27	W: 9 SAVES: 7
105	John Smiley	1	1992-1992	241	1	126	16	3.21	49.7	4.7	4.9	18	0		ERA: 10 W: 10 IP: 8 K: 10
106	Dick Woodson	5	1969-1974	561	2	107	33	3.35	48.2	3.5	4.4	31	0
107	Eric Soderholm	5	1971-1975	1345	3	105	36	0.257	40.5	8.9	6.3	38	0
108	Tom Hall	4	1968-1971	455	2	122	25	3	62.8	5	6.7	34	0		K: 8
109	Jim Thome	2	2010-2011	482	2	159	37	0.266	50.2	4.4	5.2	23	0	MVP: 18
110	George Mitterwald	7	1966-1973	1578	4	88	50	0.239	18.5	5.4	6	49	0
111	Roger Erickson	5	1978-1982	712	4	101	31	4.1	57.7	6.1	7	33	0		ERA: 8 IP: 10
112	Glenn Adams	5	1977-1981	1387	2	97	29	0.281	26.3	-1.5	-1.4	25	0
113	Nick Blackburn	6	2007-2012	818	5	86	43	4.85	42.1	2.6	3.1	30	0
114	Ron Davis	5	1982-1986	381	4	95	19	4.51	32.6	0.4	4.6	39	0		SAVES: 5,3,5,7
115	Bernie Allen	5	1962-1966	1595	4	86	32	0.246	45.6	3.5	2.6	39	0
116	Lew Ford	5	2003-2007	1514	3	96	32	0.272	37.3	3.2	3.4	44	0	MVP: 24
117	Ken Schrom	3	1983-1985	494	3	99	29	4.34	50	2.9	4.3	26	0
118	Brian Duensing	4	2009-2012	485	1	97	28	4.23	82.1	3.9	8.6	25	0
119	Dave Engle	5	1981-1985	1371	3	94	28	0.268	30.7	3.1	0.7	29	1
120	Kevin Slowey	5	2007-2011	532	3	90	39	4.66	65.8	4.4	6.3	26	0
121	Tom Burgmeier	4	1974-1977	380	1	101	24	3.77	38.5	2.1	6.6	26	0		SAVES: 8
122	Ray Corbin	5	1971-1975	652	5	95	36	3.84	20	2.7	3.5	33	0		SAVES: 8
123	Rick Reed	3	2001-2003	390	3	101	25	4.47	44	3.2	2.3	21	0
124	Todd Walker	5	1996-2000	1374	2	92	23	0.285	46.8	1.7	3.1	31	0
125	Dave Winfield	2	1993-1994	841	2	100	31	0.264	16.4	-0.4	0.6	15	0
126	Terry Steinbach	3	1997-1999	1207	3	84	30	0.256	18	3.1	3	29	0
127	Danny Thompson	7	1970-1976	2022	5	71	14	0.251	31.9	0	0.9	31	0	MVP: 23
128	Rob Wilfong	6	1977-1982	1591	3	85	22	0.262	44.6	4.3	-2	46	0
129	Matt LeCroy	7	2000-2007	1321	3	98	58	0.261	29.7	0.1	0	34	0
130	Luis Rivas	6	2000-2005	1884	4	80	30	0.262	27.7	-1.9	1	33	0		SB: 8
131	Albert Williams	5	1980-1984	642	3	99	35	4.24	61.6	5.7	7.7	33	0
132	Pete Redfern	7	1976-1982	714	4	90	42	4.54	21.2	0.8	3.3	31	0
133	Mark Salas	3	1985-1987	663	2	102	20	0.279	30.6	2.6	2.9	19	0
134	John Butcher	3	1984-1986	502	2	96	24	4.48	44.1	2	3.8	25	0
135	Craig Kusick	7	1973-1979	1184	4	107	44	0.236	31.7	3.4	2.6	31	0
136	Tim Teufel	3	1983-1985	1080	2	103	27	0.265	51	4.9	5.7	33	0
137	Mike Cubbage	5	1976-1980	1681	3	97	29	0.266	27.2	6.1	2.7	46	0
138	Jason Bartlett	4	2004-2007	1079	2	88	10	0.272	30.7	6.5	9.4	35	0
139	Jesse Crain	7	2004-2010	382	0	128	33	3.42	82.1	5.1	5.4	36	0
140	Carl Willis	5	1991-1995	286	0	120	20	3.65	46.5	2.6	5.9	28	0
141	Bill Dailey	2	1963-1964	124	1	133	7	2.76	22	1.8	3.1	17	0	MVP: 23	SAVES: 3
142	Joe Decker	4	1973-1976	503	2	94	29	4.09	32.6	3.6	4.4	25	0
143	Bobby Castillo	3	1982-1984	402	2	107	23	3.98	55.2	4.1	5.6	23	0
144	Jim Hughes	4	1974-1977	441	2	88	25	4.3	8	0.6	0.8	15	0
145	J.C. Romero	7	1999-2005	407	0	108	25	4.35	65.6	3.1	6.1	31	0
146	Ron Jackson	3	1979-1981	1154	2	96	23	0.268	14	2.1	-0.2	25	0
147	Scott Leius	6	1990-1995	1373	3	85	26	0.252	5.6	3.4	5.2	27	0
148	Luis Castillo	2	2006-2007	933	2	92	3	0.299	29.4	2.4	3.2	25	0		SB: 9
149	Rich Becker	5	1993-1997	1465	3	88	25	0.267	30.5	6	5.6	36	0
150	Lee Stange	4	1961-1964	351	1	105	20	3.61	35.9	1.5	2.4	18	0		ERA: 6
151	Glen Perkins	7	2006-2012	435	3	102	26	4.11	41.4	4.3	3.5	30	0
152	Bobby Kielty	3	2001-2003	631	0	116	23	0.269	30.1	3.1	2.4	25	0
153	Nick Punto	7	2004-2010	2365	3	74	12	0.248	-15.6	6.8	7.9	52	0
154	Mike Pagliarulo	3	1991-1993	723	2	88	9	0.272	8.7	3.6	3.3	19	0
155	Danny Valencia	3	2010-2012	989	2	91	24	0.26	19.4	0.5	2.5	23	0
156	Steve Lombardozzi	4	1985-1988	1226	3	75	19	0.233	4.9	3.4	-0.4	30	0
157	Johnny Roseboro	2	1968-1969	741	2	81	11	0.239	7.9	0.9	1.8	20	1
158	Jim Holt	7	1968-1974	1444	3	87	17	0.272	-0.7	0.7	-2.2	29	0
159	Al Newman	5	1987-1991	1647	1	59	0	0.231	-34.6	-0.3	-1.1	30	0
160	Scott Stahoviak	5	1993-1998	1019	3	91	27	0.256	2.6	0.6	1	23	0
161	Dustan Mohr	3	2001-2003	782	2	91	22	0.258	-2.6	1.5	1.7	18	0
162	Bob Randall	5	1976-1980	1325	3	74	1	0.257	5.6	2.3	-1	29	0
163	Kenny Rogers	1	2003-2003	195	1	99	13	4.57	25.4	1.7	1.7	11	0
164	Steve Brye	7	1970-1976	1641	2	90	22	0.261	-0.5	2.8	-0.3	36	0
165	Bombo Rivera	3	1978-1980	627	1	89	8	0.266	-1.5	1.9	1.2	13	0
166	Johnny Klippstein	3	1964-1966	161	0	147	10	2.45	32.7	2.2	3.9	15	0
167	Stan Williams	2	1970-1971	191	0	129	14	2.87	21.6	1	2.3	19	0		SAVES: 10
168	Hosken Powell	4	1978-1981	1468	3	83	13	0.261	-10.6	1	-0.5	27	0
169	Roy Smith	5	1986-1990	389	2	98	19	4.28	31.9	3.5	3.6	20	0
170	Darrell Jackson	5	1978-1982	411	2	97	20	4.38	35	2.7	3.7	20	0
171	Keith Atherton	3	1986-1988	235	1	111	19	3.91	38.1	2.2	5.6	20	0
172	Bill Pleis	6	1961-1966	280	0	95	21	4.07	7.5	-1.4	-0.6	16	0
173	Jim Roland	6	1962-1968	244	1	103	10	3.42	11.3	0.5	1	12	0
174	Brant Alyea	2	1970-1971	416	0	107	18	0.248	5	0.8	-1.3	13	0
175	Ray Moore	3	1961-1963	159	2	83	13	4.9	2.6	-0.8	-0.3	12	0		SAVES: 4,7
176	Mike Redmond	5	2005-2009	863	0	87	2	0.297	20	3.2	3.6	28	0
177	Roberto Kelly	2	1996-1997	569	1	105	11	0.308	24.7	1.5	1.2	15	0
178	Alex Cole	2	1994-1995	424	1	106	5	0.304	25.6	2.1	1.1	13	0		SB: 6
179	Jose Morales	3	1978-1980	674	2	106	12	0.297	27.4	-0.5	1.1	13	0
180	Bob Tewksbury	2	1997-1998	317	2	105	15	4.49	55	6	5.7	17	0
181	Ben Revere	3	2010-2012	989	2	80	0	0.278	12.6	2.6	1.4	20	0		SB: 7, 3
182	Orlando Hudson	1	2010-2010	497	1	93	6	0.268	14.7	2	3.6	14	0
183	Bill Zepp	2	1969-1970	156	1	114	9	3.34	16.5	1.2	1	9	0
184	Pedro Ramos	1	1961-1961	264	1	108	11	3.95	33.3	3.7	3.6	15	0		IP: 4 K: 6
185	John Moses	3	1988-1990	620	0	91	4	0.276	7.5	0.1	0.8	15	0
186	Greg Myers	2	1996-1997	494	1	90	11	0.279	14.2	1.8	1.4	9	0
187	Alexi Casilla	7	2006-2012	1566	4	73	11	0.248	4.3	1.7	2.5	31	0
188	Carlos Gomez	2	2008-2009	892	2	72	10	0.248	-8.8	3	4.7	19	0		SB: 7
189	Glenn Borgmann	8	1972-1979	1207	2	79	14	0.229	-1.7	4.1	0.8	37	0
190	Otis Nixon	1	1998-1998	448	1	85	1	0.297	15.2	0	-0.5	8	0		SB: 8
191	Trevor Plouffe	3	2010-2012	749	1	97	34	0.231	16.3	-0.9	0.6	14	0
192	Brendan Harris	3	2008-2010	956	1	79	14	0.251	0.1	-0.2	-0.4	19	0
193	Willie Norwood	4	1977-1980	854	1	79	18	0.242	-10.2	-1.7	-2.1	13	0
194	Dennis Hocking	11	1993-2003	2204	0	70	25	0.252	-24.7	-1.1	-0.9	43	0
195	Les Straker	2	1987-1988	237	1	105	10	4.22	38.5	2.9	3.4	13	0
196	Mark Redman	3	1999-2001	213	1	104	15	4.86	38.4	3.2	3.2	13	0
197	Scott Diamond	2	2011-2012	212	1	106	13	3.82	6.6	2.3	0.7	12	0
198	Bob Miller	2	1968-1969	191	0	120	5	2.91	25.5	1.8	2.9	12	0
199	Ron Washington	6	1981-1986	1258	2	80	17	0.265	29.3	0.1	-0.8	23	0
200	Frank Rodriguez	4	1995-1998	509	3	94	25	5.2	35.6	2.3	2	20	0
201	Boof Bonser	3	2006-2008	392	2	84	18	5.12	13.7	-0.5	-0.4	11	0
202	Vic Albury	4	1973-1976	372	2	93	18	4.11	14.8	1.2	2.7	16	0
203	Pat Mahomes	5	1992-1996	366	2	81	18	5.82	1.7	-0.9	-0.3	12	0
204	Willie Banks	3	1991-1993	259	1	93	16	4.61	13.2	1.2	2	12	0
205	Fernando Arroyo	3	1980-1982	234	1	97	13	4.3	11.3	1.2	2.9	10	0
206	Ryan Doumit	1	2012-2012	484	1	114	18	0.275	16.6	1	1.8	10	0
207	Jim Lemon	3	1961-1963	457	1	90	15	0.249	2.4	-0.4	-1.4	9	0
208	Luis Tiant	1	1970-1970	92	1	112	7	3.4	16.2	2.1	1.9	8	0
209	Pat Neshek	4	2006-2010	129	0	143	11	3.05	40.1	2.7	4	15	0
210	Terry Leach	2	1990-1991	149	0	126	3	3.38	28.2	2	2.9	11	0
211	J.J. Hardy	1	2010-2010	340	1	93	6	0.268	12.1	1.4	1.8	10	0
212	Dennys Reyes	3	2006-2008	126	0	204	10	2.14	49.6	3.7	4.2	16	0
213	Chad Allen	3	1999-2001	706	1	86	14	0.275	-3	-1.4	-1.3	10	0
214	Jason Tyner	3	2005-2007	578	0	86	1	0.299	2.9	1.3	2.1	12	0
215	Jim Dwyer	3	1988-1990	329	1	112	6	0.289	18.3	0.6	1.3	9	0
216	Bob Wells	4	1999-2002	300	0	109	18	4.47	58.4	2.7	4.1	25	0
217	Pete Filson	5	1982-1986	323	0	108	14	3.98	52	2.9	4.2	22	0
218	Hector Carrasco	4	1998-2001	256	0	108	14	4.49	51.1	2.4	3.7	18	0
219	Tony Fiore	3	2001-2003	133	0	116	11	3.92	28.7	1.5	2.6	10	0
220	Greg Swindell	2	1997-1998	182	0	130	10	3.61	54	4.1	4.7	17	0
221	Chip Hale	6	1989-1996	563	0	89	6	0.281	10	1.2	0.9	13	0
222	Dave Hollins	1	1996-1996	422	1	92	13	0.242	7.8	2.5	2.7	11	0
223	Brian Buchanan	3	2000-2002	414	0	93	16	0.258	-0.5	0.1	-0.7	6	0
224	Joe Crede	1	2009-2009	333	1	83	15	0.225	0.2	1.6	1.5	6	0
225	Frank Quilici	5	1965-1970	682	0	61	5	0.214	-8.4	-0.8	0	13	0
226	Junior Ortiz	2	1990-1991	304	0	85	0	0.28	3.7	1.4	1.6	9	0
227	Jose Mijares	4	2008-2011	153	0	133	3	3.16	31.7	2.7	2.7	12	0
228	Wayne Granger	1	1972-1972	89	1	108	4	3.01	-4.7	-1.1	-0.5	8	0		SAVES: 4
229	David West	4	1989-1992	285	1	79	15	5.33	-5	-0.3	-0.3	7	0
230	Brad Havens	3	1981-1983	367	2	84	18	5	4.7	-0.4	1.6	14	0
231	Bill Singer	1	1976-1976	172	1	96	9	3.77	4.5	0.4	0.6	7	0
232	Bill Krueger	1	1992-1992	161	1	94	10	4.3	14.7	1	1	8	0
233	Bill Hands	2	1973-1974	257	1	99	11	3.92	19.5	2.4	3	13	0
234	Jeff Reboulet	5	1992-1996	1016	0	74	9	0.248	-1.1	4.6	2.8	26	0
235	Phil Roof	6	1971-1976	619	0	75	13	0.228	-3.9	1.5	0.1	17	0
236	Jerry Terrell	5	1973-1977	1437	0	70	3	0.259	3.3	-0.5	-0.5	22	0
237	George Frazier	2	1986-1987	108	0	94	6	4.83	11.3	0.2	1.3	7	0
238	Tom Edens	2	1991-1992	109	0	129	8	3.21	23.9	1.9	2.5	10	0
239	Rick Renick	5	1968-1972	553	0	89	20	0.221	2.5	0.7	-1.4	10	0
240	Matt Capps	3	2010-2012	122	1	113	7	3.61	5.5	2.2	1.5	17	0
241	Travis Miller	7	1996-2002	267	0	98	7	5.05	21.6	-0.1	1.1	13	0
242	Gary Wayne	4	1989-1992	170	0	121	8	3.44	25.9	1.9	3.2	13	0
243	Jon Rauch	2	2009-2010	73	1	150	8	2.82	21.4	2.2	4	12	0
244	Larry Casian	5	1990-1994	144	0	95	9	4.73	11.4	0.6	2.6	10	0
245	Rich Robertson	3	1995-1997	385	2	95	17	5.17	35.6	2.4	1.3	14	0
246	Tom Herr	1	1988-1988	304	0	89	1	0.263	10.8	1.1	1.1	7	0
247	Terry Mulholland	2	2004-2005	182	1	95	5	4.89	17.9	0.5	0.8	7	0
248	Jim Deshaies	2	1993-1994	297	2	80	17	5.71	11.4	1.2	2.9	10	0
249	Johnny Briggs	1	1975-1975	264	0	106	7	0.231	5.5	1.8	1.1	9	0
250	Orlando Cabrera	1	2009-2009	242	1	94	5	0.289	10	0.3	1.1	5	0
251	Jamey Carroll	1	2012-2012	470	0	86	1	0.268	8.3	3.1	1.2	13	0
252	Randy Johnson	1	1982-1982	234	1	101	10	0.248	4.8	-0.1	0.4	5	0
253	Brian Buscher	3	2007-2009	436	1	88	8	0.266	2.5	0.5	0.4	13	0
254	Johnny Goryl	3	1962-1964	290	0	87	11	0.221	8.6	1.1	0.3	7	0
255	Don Lee	2	1961-1962	167	1	110	6	3.83	27.9	2.2	2.5	10	0
256	Neal Heaton	1	1986-1986	124	1	108	4	3.98	19.9	1.6	2.6	7	0
257	Mike Morgan	1	1998-1998	98	1	137	4	3.49	27.7	3.2	2.4	8	0
258	Steve Bedrosian	1	1991-1991	77	0	97	5	4.42	4.9	-0.1	0.3	5	0
259	Danny Goodwin	3	1979-1981	425	1	85	8	0.242	1	-0.9	-1.2	6	0
260	Joe Lis	2	1973-1974	294	1	93	9	0.238	1	-0.6	-0.4	5	0
261	Orlando Merced	1	1998-1998	204	0	98	5	0.289	1.3	-0.1	0	4	0
262	Darrell Brown	2	1983-1984	569	1	70	1	0.272	-7.8	-0.1	-2.4	8	0
263	Dave LaRoche	1	1972-1972	95	0	114	5	2.83	6.4	0.9	1.7	8	0
264	Ron Kline	1	1967-1967	71	0	92	7	3.77	0	-0.1	0.6	5	0
265	Jared Burton	1	2012-2012	62	0	187	3	2.18	7.6	1.2	0.8	8	0
266	Mike Jackson	1	2002-2002	55	0	137	2	3.27	16.5	1.1	1.2	5	0
267	John Candelaria	1	1990-1990	58	0	124	7	3.39	11	0.9	1.9	7	0
268	Gary Serum	3	1977-1979	271	1	85	10	4.72	16.8	1.2	2.2	9	0
269	Ron Schueler	1	1977-1977	134	1	92	8	4.41	7.7	0	1.1	7	0
270	Rick Lysander	3	1983-1985	242	0	105	9	4.08	19.2	-0.3	2.9	14	0
271	Paul Thormodsgard	3	1977-1979	285	1	85	12	4.74	10.5	0.3	1.2	10	0
272	Jack O'Connor	4	1981-1984	249	1	85	13	4.99	3.6	-0.8	0.7	7	0
273	Tom Prince	3	2001-2003	361	0	77	13	0.219	-0.1	1.8	3.2	12	0
274	Lenny Webster	5	1989-1993	284	0	89	5	0.254	5.3	0.8	0.3	6	0
275	Freddie Toliver	2	1988-1989	143	1	83	8	4.95	3.9	0.3	0.6	6	0
276	Charlie Lea	1	1988-1988	130	1	84	7	4.85	-0.3	-0.3	0.2	4	0
277	Don Baylor	1	1987-1987	49	0	89	0	0.286	0.4	0	0	1	0
278	Henry Blanco	1	2004-2004	315	1	60	10	0.206	-11.6	0.2	1.5	5	0
279	Paul Sorrento	3	1989-1991	189	0	91	9	0.222	0.8	-0.4	-0.2	2	0
280	Bobby Mitchell	2	1982-1983	606	1	78	3	0.244	-6.4	0.8	-0.3	12	0
281	Jay Canizaro	2	2000-2002	458	1	72	7	0.255	-2.3	-0.7	-1.3	8	0
282	Rick Sofield	3	1979-1981	612	1	70	9	0.243	-18.7	-1	-3.3	11	0
283	Juan Castro	2	2005-2006	428	1	64	6	0.248	-7.7	-1.6	0.6	10	0
284	Brent Gates	2	1998-1999	639	1	69	6	0.252	-12.5	0.8	-0.3	12	0
285	Matt Walbeck	3	1994-1996	946	2	47	8	0.23	-40.8	-1.7	-3.6	13	0
286	Jerry Zimmerman	7	1962-1968	790	1	46	3	0.204	-30	-1.5	-1.1	20	0
287	Lenny Faedo	5	1980-1984	529	0	63	5	0.251	2	-0.2	-2.4	7	0
288	Michael Ryan	4	2002-2005	260	0	87	7	0.265	0.9	-0.3	-0.2	5	0
289	Pete Cimino	2	1965-1966	65	0	127	2	2.88	6.4	0.2	0.6	5	0
290	Dwight Siebler	5	1963-1967	117	0	107	4	3.45	8.1	-0.1	0.4	5	0
291	Dave Stevens	4	1994-1997	191	1	85	14	5.82	12	-0.7	0.6	11	0
292	Mark Portugal	4	1985-1988	238	1	84	11	5.13	10.7	0.5	2.4	11	0
293	Joe Bonikowski	1	1962-1962	99	1	106	5	3.88	13.6	1	1	6	0
294	Matt Garza	2	2006-2007	133	1	98	8	4.47	12.1	0.7	0	6	0
295	Len Whitehouse	3	1983-1985	112	0	99	9	4.33	14.7	0	2	8	0
296	Graig Nettles	3	1967-1969	304	0	99	12	0.224	3.9	0.8	0.3	8	0
297	Chris Parmelee	2	2011-2012	268	0	114	9	0.265	5.2	0.6	0.7	8	0
298	Paul Ratliff	3	1963-1971	214	0	102	8	0.238	6.7	1.1	-0.2	10	0
299	Gerry Arrigo	4	1961-1964	131	0	86	8	4.31	2	0.2	0.7	6	0
300	John Verhoeven	2	1980-1981	151	0	107	3	3.98	10.5	0.3	1.6	7	0

Spoiler: Original

Select Show

27 thoughts on “One man’s opinion of the top300 Twins ever”

and the 415 Twins who failed to make the cut

Spoiler	Select Show
Player Matt Tolbert 4 2008-2011 Pete Mackanin 2 1980-1981 David McCarty 3 1993-1995 Bill Tuttle 3 1961-1963 Sal Butera 4 1980-1987 Drew Butera 3 2010-2012 Dave Edwards 3 1978-1980 Jerry Kindall 2 1964-1965 Rich Chiles 2 1977-1978 Sandy Valdespino 3 1965-1967 Rondell White 2 2006-2007 Luis Rodriguez 3 2005-2007 Jim Nettles 3 1970-1972 Javier Valentin 4 1997-2002 Houston Jimenez 2 1983-1984 Billy Martin 1 1961-1961 Carmen Castillo 3 1989-1991 Charlie Manuel 4 1969-1972 Luis Gomez 4 1974-1977 Mark Davidson 3 1986-1988 Brian Dozier 1 2012-2012 Luke Hughes 3 2010-2012 Wally Backman 1 1989-1989 Ron Clark 4 1966-1969 Frank Kostro 5 1964-1969 Russ Nixon 2 1966-1967 Dave McKay 2 1975-1976 Larry Wolfe 2 1977-1978 Jason Repko 2 2010-2011 Anthony Swarzak 3 2009-2012 Dave Meier 2 1984-1985 Alex Ochoa 1 1998-1998 Andy Kosco 3 1965-1967 Terry Tiffee 3 2004-2006 Jesus Vega 3 1979-1982 Mike Lamb 1 2008-2008 Terry Jorgensen 3 1989-1993 Tsuyoshi Nishioka 2 2011-2012 Fred Manrique 1 1990-1990 Jackie Hernandez 2 1967-1968 Midre Cummings 2 1999-2000 Greg Colbrunn 1 1997-1997 Butch Huskey 1 2000-2000 Ray Smith 3 1981-1983 Brent Brede 2 1996-1997 Bill Butler 3 1974-1977 Scott Aldred 2 1996-1997 Dan Masteller 1 1995-1995 Billy Beane 2 1986-1987 Jeff Reed 3 1984-1986 Matt Merullo 1 1995-1995 Steve Luebber 3 1971-1976 Nelson Liriano 1 1990-1990 Mike Stenhouse 1 1985-1985 Jason Maxwell 2 2000-2001 Tony Batista 1 2006-2006 George Banks 3 1962-1964 Chris Gomez 1 2003-2003 Hal Naragon 2 1961-1962 Jose Offerman 1 2004-2004 Rene Tosoni 1 2011-2011 Joe Nossek 3 1964-1966 Alex Burnett 3 2010-2012 Eddie Bane 3 1973-1976 Tom Nieto 2 1987-1988 Paul Hartzell 1 1979-1979 Craig Monroe 1 2008-2008 Darin Mastroianni 1 2012-2012 Danny Walton 2 1973-1975 Jose Morales 3 2007-2010 Billy Gardner 1 1961-1961 Jeff Cirillo 1 2007-2007 Jose Valdivielso 1 1961-1961 Shane Rawley 1 1989-1989 Livan Hernandez 1 2008-2008 Marcus Jensen 1 2000-2000 Jim Eisenreich 3 1982-1984 Sergio Ferrer 2 1974-1975 Terry Felton 4 1979-1982 Chris Latham 3 1997-1999 Pedro Florimon 1 2012-2012 Jose Parra 2 1995-1996 Dan Monzon 2 1972-1973 Darrin Jackson 1 1997-1997 Chad Moeller 1 2000-2000 Adam Everett 1 2008-2008 Tom Kelly 1 1975-1975 Dan Dobbek 1 1961-1961 Bruce Look 1 1968-1968 Bob Gorinski 1 1977-1977 Tom Tischinski 3 1969-1971 Derek Parks 3 1992-1994 Michael Restovich 3 2002-2004 Ted Lepcio 1 1961-1961 Carlos Pulido 3 1994-2004 Dan Naulty 3 1996-1998 Jerald Clark 1 1995-1995 Joe Niekro 2 1987-1988 Matt Kinney 2 2000-2002 Liam Hendriks 2 2011-2012 Tim Drummond 2 1989-1990 Dan Serafini 3 1996-1998 Reno Bertoia 1 1961-1961 Rene Rivera 1 2011-2011 Jack Cressend 3 2000-2002 Ed Hodge 1 1984-1984 Rusty Kuntz 1 1983-1983 Todd Ritchie 2 1997-1998 Alvaro Espinoza 3 1984-1986 Larry Milbourne 1 1982-1982 Mike Lincoln 2 1999-2000 J.T. Bruett 2 1992-1993 Joe Altobelli 1 1961-1961 Paul Abbott 3 1990-1992 Ramon Ortiz 1 2007-2007 Jeff Holly 3 1977-1979 Mike Bacsik 2 1979-1980 Mike Walters 2 1983-1984 Benj Sampson 2 1998-1999 Randy Hundley 1 1974-1974 Dan Perkins 1 1999-1999 Cole De Vries 1 2012-2012 Doug Baker 3 1988-1990 Jim Snyder 3 1961-1964 Mark Funderburk 2 1981-1985 Dave Johnson 2 1977-1978 Jeff Manship 4 2009-2012 Julio Becquer 2 1961-1963 Garry Roggenburk 3 1963-1966 Chris Heintz 3 2005-2007 Mike Hartley 1 1993-1993 Mike Durant 1 1996-1996 Josh Rabe 2 2006-2007 Scott Ullger 1 1983-1983 Sam Deduno 1 2012-2012 Todd Sears 2 2002-2003 Garrett Jones 1 2007-2007 Scott Klingenbeck 2 1995-1996 Greg Hansell 1 1996-1996 Georges Maranda 1 1962-1962 Bernardo Brito 3 1992-1995 Brian Dinkelman 1 2011-2011 Jim Strickland 3 1971-1973 Mike Adams 2 1972-1973 Mike Dyer 1 1989-1989 Joe Benson 1 2011-2011 Joe Roa 1 2004-2004 Don Cooper 2 1981-1982 Ron Henry 2 1961-1964 Sean Bergman 1 2000-2000 Grant Balfour 3 2001-2004 Brian Bass 1 2008-2008 George Tsamis 1 1993-1993 Jay Ryan 2 1999-2000 Ted Sadowski 2 1961-1962 Brent Abernathy 1 2005-2005 Rick Dempsey 4 1969-1972 Damian Miller 1 1997-1997 Chuck Baker 1 1981-1981 Matt Carson 1 2012-2012 R.A. Dickey 1 2009-2009 Pat Bourque 1 1974-1974 Quinton McCracken 1 2001-2001 Randy Ruiz 1 2008-2008 Frank Eufemia 1 1985-1985 P.J. Walters 1 2012-2012 Erik Schullstrom 2 1994-1995 Pete Hamm 2 1970-1971 Augie Ojeda 1 2004-2004 Willie Eyre 1 2006-2006 Roy Lee Jackson 1 1986-1986 Casey Blake 3 2000-2002 John Barnes 2 2000-2001 Stan Perzanowski 1 1978-1978 Jerry Fosnow 2 1964-1965 Kevin Maas 1 1995-1995 Francisco Oliveras 1 1989-1989 Danny Fife 2 1973-1974 Mel Nelson 2 1965-1967 Bobby Keppel 1 2009-2009 Dan Schatzeder 2 1987-1988 Greg Wells 1 1982-1982 Craig Breslow 2 2008-2009 Andre David 2 1984-1986 Curt Wardle 2 1984-1985 Steve Carlton 2 1987-1988 Bret Boone 1 2005-2005 John Pacella 1 1982-1982 Jarvis Brown 2 1991-1992 Jeff Gray 1 2012-2012 Donnie Hill 1 1992-1992 Seth Greisinger 1 2004-2004 Tim Corcoran 1 1981-1981 Paul Boris 1 1982-1982 German Gonzalez 2 1988-1989 Aaron Fultz 1 2004-2004 Al Schroll 1 1961-1961 Frank Pastore 1 1986-1986 Joe Grzenda 1 1969-1969 Hal Haydel 2 1970-1971 Mike Pazik 3 1975-1977 Wally Post 1 1963-1963 Jay Ward 2 1963-1964 Greg Thayer 1 1978-1978 Jim Ollom 2 1966-1967 Chuck Stobbs 1 1961-1961 John Sutton 1 1978-1978 Frank Sullivan 2 1962-1963 Ken Sanders 1 1973-1973 Vic Wertz 1 1963-1963 Brett Merriman 2 1993-1994 Eduardo Escobar 1 2012-2012 Ron Mahay 2 2009-2010 Alex Prieto 2 2003-2004 Greg Johnston 2 1980-1981 Pat Borders 1 2004-2004 Phil Nevin 1 2006-2006 Steve Dunn 2 1994-1995 Phil Dumatrait 1 2011-2011 Glenn Williams 1 2005-2005 Jon Shave 1 1998-1998 Bob Kipper 1 1992-1992 Steve Barber 2 1970-1971 Mark Wiley 1 1975-1975 Bob Gebhard 2 1971-1972 Larry Pashnick 1 1984-1984 John Christensen 1 1988-1988 Orlando Mercado 1 1989-1989 Pat Putnam 1 1984-1984 Sidney Ponson 1 2007-2007 Mike Poepping 1 1975-1975 Rob Bowen 2 2003-2004 Jeff Little 1 1982-1982 Pat Kelly 2 1967-1968 Oscar Munoz 1 1995-1995 Casey Fien 1 2012-2012 Kevin Campbell 2 1994-1995 Matt Macri 1 2008-2008 Bryan Oelkers 1 1983-1983 Jason Marquis 1 2012-2012 Greg Harris 1 1995-1995 Chris Speier 1 1984-1984 Darren Reed 1 1992-1992 Chris Pittaro 2 1986-1987 Derek Lee 1 1993-1993 Tom Norton 1 1972-1972 Luis Ayala 1 2009-2009 Mac Scarce 1 1978-1978 Danny Ardoin 1 2000-2000 Bud Bulling 1 1977-1977 Elmer Valo 1 1961-1961 Erik Komatsu 1 2012-2012 Kyle Waldrop 2 2011-2012 Paul Powell 1 1971-1971 Esmerling Vasquez 1 2012-2012 George Thomas 1 1971-1971 Dennis Burtt 2 1985-1986 Bill Bethea 1 1964-1964 Jerry Crider 1 1969-1969 Mike Hart 1 1984-1984 Al Woods 1 1986-1986 Tommy Watkins 1 2007-2007 Ruben Sierra 1 2006-2006 Tom Lundstedt 1 1975-1975 Clete Thomas 1 2012-2012 Danny McDevitt 1 1961-1961 Bob Veselic 2 1980-1981 Wilson Ramos 1 2010-2010 Travis Baptist 1 1998-1998 Jay Pettibone 1 1983-1983 Greg Brummett 1 1993-1993 Erik Bennett 1 1996-1996 Hank Izquierdo 1 1967-1967 Jack Savage 1 1990-1990 Adam Johnson 2 2001-2003 Mike Kinnunen 1 1980-1980 Tyler Robertson 1 2012-2012 Sam Perlozzo 1 1977-1977 Brad Thomas 3 2001-2004 Herman Hill 2 1969-1970 Jim Hoey 1 2011-2011 Mike Fornieles 1 1963-1963 Joe Klink 1 1987-1987 Brian Raabe 2 1995-1996 Scott Watkins 1 1995-1995 Randy St. Claire 1 1989-1989 Mike Milchin 1 1996-1996 Cleatus Davidson 1 1999-1999 Ron Keller 2 1966-1968 Carmen Cali 1 2007-2007 Mike Cook 1 1989-1989 Jim Winn 1 1988-1988 Bert Cueto 1 1961-1961 Ed Palmquist 1 1961-1961 Denny Neagle 1 1991-1991 Philip Humber 2 2008-2009 Julio DePaula 1 2007-2007 Juan Agosto 1 1986-1986 Todd Jones 1 2001-2001 Mo Sanford 1 1995-1995 Ruben Gomez 1 1962-1962 Steve Howe 1 1985-1985 Shane Bowers 1 1997-1997 Paul Giel 1 1961-1961 Joe McCabe 1 1964-1964 Randy Bass 1 1977-1977 Bobby Korecky 1 2008-2008 Garland Shifflett 1 1964-1964 Jim Lewis 1 1983-1983 Marty Martinez 1 1962-1962 Chris Herrmann 1 2012-2012 Eric Bullock 1 1988-1988 Steve Shields 1 1989-1989 Steve Holm 1 2011-2011 Sean Burroughs 1 2012-2012 Luis Perdomo 1 2012-2012 Walt Bond 1 1967-1967 Danny Morris 2 1968-1969 Kelvin Torve 1 1988-1988 Mark Brown 1 1985-1985 Bill Latham 1 1986-1986 Ray Fontenot 1 1986-1986 Minnie Mendoza 1 1970-1970 Alejandro Sanchez 1 1986-1986 John Sevcik 1 1965-1965 James Baldwin 1 2003-2003 Jackie Collum 1 1962-1962 Lester Oliveros 2 2011-2012 Don Carrithers 1 1977-1977 Ken Brett 1 1979-1979 Cotton Nash 2 1969-1970 Mike Nakamura 1 2003-2003 Kevin Jarvis 1 1997-1997 Gary Dotter 3 1961-1964 Lee Tunnell 1 1989-1989 Karl Best 1 1988-1988 Mike Maksudian 1 1993-1993 Roric Harrison 1 1978-1978 Kevin Frederick 1 2002-2002 Corky Miller 1 2005-2005 Dusty Hughes 1 2011-2011 Vic Rodriguez 1 1989-1989 Fred Lasher 1 1963-1963 Buzz Stephen 1 1968-1968 Sean Henn 1 2009-2009 Matt Maloney 1 2012-2012 Rich Garces 2 1990-1993 Travis Bowyer 1 2005-2005 Jim Donohue 1 1962-1962 Darnell McDonald 1 2007-2007 David Lamb 1 2002-2002 Brian Fuentes 1 2010-2010 Chuck James 1 2011-2011 Greg Booker 1 1989-1989 Vince Horsman 1 1995-1995 Tom Klawitter 1 1985-1985 Keith Garagozzo 1 1994-1994 Rob Radlosky 1 1999-1999 Carroll Hardy 1 1967-1967 Howie Clark 1 2008-2008 Jeff Bittiger 1 1987-1987 Dave Gassner 1 2005-2005 Jake Jacobs 1 1961-1961 Gregg Olson 1 1997-1997 Riccardo Ingram 1 1995-1995 Jim Manning 1 1962-1962 Charlie Walters 1 1969-1969 J.D. Durbin 1 2004-2004 Bill Fischer 1 1964-1964 Mike Mason 1 1988-1988 Bud Bloomfield 1 1964-1964 Dwight Lowry 1 1988-1988 Warren Morris 1 2002-2002 Anthony Slama 2 2010-2011 Mike Fetters 1 2003-2003 John Hobbs 1 1981-1981 Jim Shellenback 1 1977-1977 Keith Comstock 1 1984-1984 Bill Whitby 1 1964-1964 Pete Whisenant 1 1961-1961 Tom Quinlan 1 1996-1996 Matt Fox 1 2010-2010 Rich Yett 2 1985-1990 Danny Mota 1 2000-2000 Mike Duvall 1 2001-2001 Randy Niemann 1 1987-1987 Gary Rath 1 1999-1999 Luis Quinones 1 1992-1992 Billy Consolo 1 1961-1961 Eric Hacker 1 2011-2011 Tack Wilson 1 1983-1983 Sal Campisi 1 1971-1971 Jesse Orosco 1 2003-2003 Don Williams 1 1963-1963 Jose Rodriguez 1 2002-2002 Jason Miller 1 2007-2007 Tippy Martinez 1 1988-1988 Jason Pridie 2 2008-2009 Dan Graham 1 1979-1979 Randy Flores 1 2010-2010 Bucky Brandon 1 1969-1969 Kevin Stanfield 1 1979-1979 Mike Smith 1 2006-2006 Armando Gabino 1 2009-2009 Bucky Guth 1 1972-1972 Greg Olson 1 1989-1989 Justin Huber 1 2009-2009 Chuck Nieson 1 1964-1964 Juan Morillo 1 2009-2009 Mauro Gozzo 1 1992-1992 Joe Beimel 1 2004-2004 Kevin Mulvey 1 2009-2009 Ryan Jorgensen 1 2008-2008 Rob Delaney 1 2010-2010 Fred Bruckbauer 1 1961-1961

Spoiler

Select Show

Player
Matt Tolbert 4 2008-2011
Pete Mackanin 2 1980-1981
David McCarty 3 1993-1995
Bill Tuttle 3 1961-1963
Sal Butera 4 1980-1987
Drew Butera 3 2010-2012
Dave Edwards 3 1978-1980
Jerry Kindall 2 1964-1965
Rich Chiles 2 1977-1978
Sandy Valdespino 3 1965-1967
Rondell White 2 2006-2007
Luis Rodriguez 3 2005-2007
Jim Nettles 3 1970-1972
Javier Valentin 4 1997-2002
Houston Jimenez 2 1983-1984
Billy Martin 1 1961-1961
Carmen Castillo 3 1989-1991
Charlie Manuel 4 1969-1972
Luis Gomez 4 1974-1977
Mark Davidson 3 1986-1988
Brian Dozier 1 2012-2012
Luke Hughes 3 2010-2012
Wally Backman 1 1989-1989
Ron Clark 4 1966-1969
Frank Kostro 5 1964-1969
Russ Nixon 2 1966-1967
Dave McKay 2 1975-1976
Larry Wolfe 2 1977-1978
Jason Repko 2 2010-2011
Anthony Swarzak 3 2009-2012
Dave Meier 2 1984-1985
Alex Ochoa 1 1998-1998
Andy Kosco 3 1965-1967
Terry Tiffee 3 2004-2006
Jesus Vega 3 1979-1982
Mike Lamb 1 2008-2008
Terry Jorgensen 3 1989-1993
Tsuyoshi Nishioka 2 2011-2012
Fred Manrique 1 1990-1990
Jackie Hernandez 2 1967-1968
Midre Cummings 2 1999-2000
Greg Colbrunn 1 1997-1997
Butch Huskey 1 2000-2000
Ray Smith 3 1981-1983
Brent Brede 2 1996-1997
Bill Butler 3 1974-1977
Scott Aldred 2 1996-1997
Dan Masteller 1 1995-1995
Billy Beane 2 1986-1987
Jeff Reed 3 1984-1986
Matt Merullo 1 1995-1995
Steve Luebber 3 1971-1976
Nelson Liriano 1 1990-1990
Mike Stenhouse 1 1985-1985
Jason Maxwell 2 2000-2001
Tony Batista 1 2006-2006
George Banks 3 1962-1964
Chris Gomez 1 2003-2003
Hal Naragon 2 1961-1962
Jose Offerman 1 2004-2004
Rene Tosoni 1 2011-2011
Joe Nossek 3 1964-1966
Alex Burnett 3 2010-2012
Eddie Bane 3 1973-1976
Tom Nieto 2 1987-1988
Paul Hartzell 1 1979-1979
Craig Monroe 1 2008-2008
Darin Mastroianni 1 2012-2012
Danny Walton 2 1973-1975
Jose Morales 3 2007-2010
Billy Gardner 1 1961-1961
Jeff Cirillo 1 2007-2007
Jose Valdivielso 1 1961-1961
Shane Rawley 1 1989-1989
Livan Hernandez 1 2008-2008
Marcus Jensen 1 2000-2000
Jim Eisenreich 3 1982-1984
Sergio Ferrer 2 1974-1975
Terry Felton 4 1979-1982
Chris Latham 3 1997-1999
Pedro Florimon 1 2012-2012
Jose Parra 2 1995-1996
Dan Monzon 2 1972-1973
Darrin Jackson 1 1997-1997
Chad Moeller 1 2000-2000
Adam Everett 1 2008-2008
Tom Kelly 1 1975-1975
Dan Dobbek 1 1961-1961
Bruce Look 1 1968-1968
Bob Gorinski 1 1977-1977
Tom Tischinski 3 1969-1971
Derek Parks 3 1992-1994
Michael Restovich 3 2002-2004
Ted Lepcio 1 1961-1961
Carlos Pulido 3 1994-2004
Dan Naulty 3 1996-1998
Jerald Clark 1 1995-1995
Joe Niekro 2 1987-1988
Matt Kinney 2 2000-2002
Liam Hendriks 2 2011-2012
Tim Drummond 2 1989-1990
Dan Serafini 3 1996-1998
Reno Bertoia 1 1961-1961
Rene Rivera 1 2011-2011
Jack Cressend 3 2000-2002
Ed Hodge 1 1984-1984
Rusty Kuntz 1 1983-1983
Todd Ritchie 2 1997-1998
Alvaro Espinoza 3 1984-1986
Larry Milbourne 1 1982-1982
Mike Lincoln 2 1999-2000
J.T. Bruett 2 1992-1993
Joe Altobelli 1 1961-1961
Paul Abbott 3 1990-1992
Ramon Ortiz 1 2007-2007
Jeff Holly 3 1977-1979
Mike Bacsik 2 1979-1980
Mike Walters 2 1983-1984
Benj Sampson 2 1998-1999
Randy Hundley 1 1974-1974
Dan Perkins 1 1999-1999
Cole De Vries 1 2012-2012
Doug Baker 3 1988-1990
Jim Snyder 3 1961-1964
Mark Funderburk 2 1981-1985
Dave Johnson 2 1977-1978
Jeff Manship 4 2009-2012
Julio Becquer 2 1961-1963
Garry Roggenburk 3 1963-1966
Chris Heintz 3 2005-2007
Mike Hartley 1 1993-1993
Mike Durant 1 1996-1996
Josh Rabe 2 2006-2007
Scott Ullger 1 1983-1983
Sam Deduno 1 2012-2012
Todd Sears 2 2002-2003
Garrett Jones 1 2007-2007
Scott Klingenbeck 2 1995-1996
Greg Hansell 1 1996-1996
Georges Maranda 1 1962-1962
Bernardo Brito 3 1992-1995
Brian Dinkelman 1 2011-2011
Jim Strickland 3 1971-1973
Mike Adams 2 1972-1973
Mike Dyer 1 1989-1989
Joe Benson 1 2011-2011
Joe Roa 1 2004-2004
Don Cooper 2 1981-1982
Ron Henry 2 1961-1964
Sean Bergman 1 2000-2000
Grant Balfour 3 2001-2004
Brian Bass 1 2008-2008
George Tsamis 1 1993-1993
Jay Ryan 2 1999-2000
Ted Sadowski 2 1961-1962
Brent Abernathy 1 2005-2005
Rick Dempsey 4 1969-1972
Damian Miller 1 1997-1997
Chuck Baker 1 1981-1981
Matt Carson 1 2012-2012
R.A. Dickey 1 2009-2009
Pat Bourque 1 1974-1974
Quinton McCracken 1 2001-2001
Randy Ruiz 1 2008-2008
Frank Eufemia 1 1985-1985
P.J. Walters 1 2012-2012
Erik Schullstrom 2 1994-1995
Pete Hamm 2 1970-1971
Augie Ojeda 1 2004-2004
Willie Eyre 1 2006-2006
Roy Lee Jackson 1 1986-1986
Casey Blake 3 2000-2002
John Barnes 2 2000-2001
Stan Perzanowski 1 1978-1978
Jerry Fosnow 2 1964-1965
Kevin Maas 1 1995-1995
Francisco Oliveras 1 1989-1989
Danny Fife 2 1973-1974
Mel Nelson 2 1965-1967
Bobby Keppel 1 2009-2009
Dan Schatzeder 2 1987-1988
Greg Wells 1 1982-1982
Craig Breslow 2 2008-2009
Andre David 2 1984-1986
Curt Wardle 2 1984-1985
Steve Carlton 2 1987-1988
Bret Boone 1 2005-2005
John Pacella 1 1982-1982
Jarvis Brown 2 1991-1992
Jeff Gray 1 2012-2012
Donnie Hill 1 1992-1992
Seth Greisinger 1 2004-2004
Tim Corcoran 1 1981-1981
Paul Boris 1 1982-1982
German Gonzalez 2 1988-1989
Aaron Fultz 1 2004-2004
Al Schroll 1 1961-1961
Frank Pastore 1 1986-1986
Joe Grzenda 1 1969-1969
Hal Haydel 2 1970-1971
Mike Pazik 3 1975-1977
Wally Post 1 1963-1963
Jay Ward 2 1963-1964
Greg Thayer 1 1978-1978
Jim Ollom 2 1966-1967
Chuck Stobbs 1 1961-1961
John Sutton 1 1978-1978
Frank Sullivan 2 1962-1963
Ken Sanders 1 1973-1973
Vic Wertz 1 1963-1963
Brett Merriman 2 1993-1994
Eduardo Escobar 1 2012-2012
Ron Mahay 2 2009-2010
Alex Prieto 2 2003-2004
Greg Johnston 2 1980-1981
Pat Borders 1 2004-2004
Phil Nevin 1 2006-2006
Steve Dunn 2 1994-1995
Phil Dumatrait 1 2011-2011
Glenn Williams 1 2005-2005
Jon Shave 1 1998-1998
Bob Kipper 1 1992-1992
Steve Barber 2 1970-1971
Mark Wiley 1 1975-1975
Bob Gebhard 2 1971-1972
Larry Pashnick 1 1984-1984
John Christensen 1 1988-1988
Orlando Mercado 1 1989-1989
Pat Putnam 1 1984-1984
Sidney Ponson 1 2007-2007
Mike Poepping 1 1975-1975
Rob Bowen 2 2003-2004
Jeff Little 1 1982-1982
Pat Kelly 2 1967-1968
Oscar Munoz 1 1995-1995
Casey Fien 1 2012-2012
Kevin Campbell 2 1994-1995
Matt Macri 1 2008-2008
Bryan Oelkers 1 1983-1983
Jason Marquis 1 2012-2012
Greg Harris 1 1995-1995
Chris Speier 1 1984-1984
Darren Reed 1 1992-1992
Chris Pittaro 2 1986-1987
Derek Lee 1 1993-1993
Tom Norton 1 1972-1972
Luis Ayala 1 2009-2009
Mac Scarce 1 1978-1978
Danny Ardoin 1 2000-2000
Bud Bulling 1 1977-1977
Elmer Valo 1 1961-1961
Erik Komatsu 1 2012-2012
Kyle Waldrop 2 2011-2012
Paul Powell 1 1971-1971
Esmerling Vasquez 1 2012-2012
George Thomas 1 1971-1971
Dennis Burtt 2 1985-1986
Bill Bethea 1 1964-1964
Jerry Crider 1 1969-1969
Mike Hart 1 1984-1984
Al Woods 1 1986-1986
Tommy Watkins 1 2007-2007
Ruben Sierra 1 2006-2006
Tom Lundstedt 1 1975-1975
Clete Thomas 1 2012-2012
Danny McDevitt 1 1961-1961
Bob Veselic 2 1980-1981
Wilson Ramos 1 2010-2010
Travis Baptist 1 1998-1998
Jay Pettibone 1 1983-1983
Greg Brummett 1 1993-1993
Erik Bennett 1 1996-1996
Hank Izquierdo 1 1967-1967
Jack Savage 1 1990-1990
Adam Johnson 2 2001-2003
Mike Kinnunen 1 1980-1980
Tyler Robertson 1 2012-2012
Sam Perlozzo 1 1977-1977
Brad Thomas 3 2001-2004
Herman Hill 2 1969-1970
Jim Hoey 1 2011-2011
Mike Fornieles 1 1963-1963
Joe Klink 1 1987-1987
Brian Raabe 2 1995-1996
Scott Watkins 1 1995-1995
Randy St. Claire 1 1989-1989
Mike Milchin 1 1996-1996
Cleatus Davidson 1 1999-1999
Ron Keller 2 1966-1968
Carmen Cali 1 2007-2007
Mike Cook 1 1989-1989
Jim Winn 1 1988-1988
Bert Cueto 1 1961-1961
Ed Palmquist 1 1961-1961
Denny Neagle 1 1991-1991
Philip Humber 2 2008-2009
Julio DePaula 1 2007-2007
Juan Agosto 1 1986-1986
Todd Jones 1 2001-2001
Mo Sanford 1 1995-1995
Ruben Gomez 1 1962-1962
Steve Howe 1 1985-1985
Shane Bowers 1 1997-1997
Paul Giel 1 1961-1961
Joe McCabe 1 1964-1964
Randy Bass 1 1977-1977
Bobby Korecky 1 2008-2008
Garland Shifflett 1 1964-1964
Jim Lewis 1 1983-1983
Marty Martinez 1 1962-1962
Chris Herrmann 1 2012-2012
Eric Bullock 1 1988-1988
Steve Shields 1 1989-1989
Steve Holm 1 2011-2011
Sean Burroughs 1 2012-2012
Luis Perdomo 1 2012-2012
Walt Bond 1 1967-1967
Danny Morris 2 1968-1969
Kelvin Torve 1 1988-1988
Mark Brown 1 1985-1985
Bill Latham 1 1986-1986
Ray Fontenot 1 1986-1986
Minnie Mendoza 1 1970-1970
Alejandro Sanchez 1 1986-1986
John Sevcik 1 1965-1965
James Baldwin 1 2003-2003
Jackie Collum 1 1962-1962
Lester Oliveros 2 2011-2012
Don Carrithers 1 1977-1977
Ken Brett 1 1979-1979
Cotton Nash 2 1969-1970
Mike Nakamura 1 2003-2003
Kevin Jarvis 1 1997-1997
Gary Dotter 3 1961-1964
Lee Tunnell 1 1989-1989
Karl Best 1 1988-1988
Mike Maksudian 1 1993-1993
Roric Harrison 1 1978-1978
Kevin Frederick 1 2002-2002
Corky Miller 1 2005-2005
Dusty Hughes 1 2011-2011
Vic Rodriguez 1 1989-1989
Fred Lasher 1 1963-1963
Buzz Stephen 1 1968-1968
Sean Henn 1 2009-2009
Matt Maloney 1 2012-2012
Rich Garces 2 1990-1993
Travis Bowyer 1 2005-2005
Jim Donohue 1 1962-1962
Darnell McDonald 1 2007-2007
David Lamb 1 2002-2002
Brian Fuentes 1 2010-2010
Chuck James 1 2011-2011
Greg Booker 1 1989-1989
Vince Horsman 1 1995-1995
Tom Klawitter 1 1985-1985
Keith Garagozzo 1 1994-1994
Rob Radlosky 1 1999-1999
Carroll Hardy 1 1967-1967
Howie Clark 1 2008-2008
Jeff Bittiger 1 1987-1987
Dave Gassner 1 2005-2005
Jake Jacobs 1 1961-1961
Gregg Olson 1 1997-1997
Riccardo Ingram 1 1995-1995
Jim Manning 1 1962-1962
Charlie Walters 1 1969-1969
J.D. Durbin 1 2004-2004
Bill Fischer 1 1964-1964
Mike Mason 1 1988-1988
Bud Bloomfield 1 1964-1964
Dwight Lowry 1 1988-1988
Warren Morris 1 2002-2002
Anthony Slama 2 2010-2011
Mike Fetters 1 2003-2003
John Hobbs 1 1981-1981
Jim Shellenback 1 1977-1977
Keith Comstock 1 1984-1984
Bill Whitby 1 1964-1964
Pete Whisenant 1 1961-1961
Tom Quinlan 1 1996-1996
Matt Fox 1 2010-2010
Rich Yett 2 1985-1990
Danny Mota 1 2000-2000
Mike Duvall 1 2001-2001
Randy Niemann 1 1987-1987
Gary Rath 1 1999-1999
Luis Quinones 1 1992-1992
Billy Consolo 1 1961-1961
Eric Hacker 1 2011-2011
Tack Wilson 1 1983-1983
Sal Campisi 1 1971-1971
Jesse Orosco 1 2003-2003
Don Williams 1 1963-1963
Jose Rodriguez 1 2002-2002
Jason Miller 1 2007-2007
Tippy Martinez 1 1988-1988
Jason Pridie 2 2008-2009
Dan Graham 1 1979-1979
Randy Flores 1 2010-2010
Bucky Brandon 1 1969-1969
Kevin Stanfield 1 1979-1979
Mike Smith 1 2006-2006
Armando Gabino 1 2009-2009
Bucky Guth 1 1972-1972
Greg Olson 1 1989-1989
Justin Huber 1 2009-2009
Chuck Nieson 1 1964-1964
Juan Morillo 1 2009-2009
Mauro Gozzo 1 1992-1992
Joe Beimel 1 2004-2004
Kevin Mulvey 1 2009-2009
Ryan Jorgensen 1 2008-2008
Rob Delaney 1 2010-2010
Fred Bruckbauer 1 1961-1961

In the interest of not ruining your list in case I messed up:

Spoiler

Select Show

Player	Years	Date Range
Matt Tolbert	4	2008-2011
Pete Mackanin	2	1980-1981
David McCarty	3	1993-1995
Bill Tuttle	3	1961-1963
Sal Butera	4	1980-1987
Drew Butera	3	2010-2012
Dave Edwards	3	1978-1980
Jerry Kindall	2	1964-1965
Rich Chiles	2	1977-1978
Sandy Valdespino	3	1965-1967
Rondell White	2	2006-2007
Luis Rodriguez	3	2005-2007
Jim Nettles	3	1970-1972
Javier Valentin	4	1997-2002
Houston Jimenez	2	1983-1984
Billy Martin	1	1961-1961
Carmen Castillo	3	1989-1991
Charlie Manuel	4	1969-1972
Luis Gomez	4	1974-1977
Mark Davidson	3	1986-1988
Brian Dozier	1	2012-2012
Luke Hughes	3	2010-2012
Wally Backman	1	1989-1989
Ron Clark	4	1966-1969
Frank Kostro	5	1964-1969
Russ Nixon	2	1966-1967
Dave McKay	2	1975-1976
Larry Wolfe	2	1977-1978
Jason Repko	2	2010-2011
Anthony Swarzak	3	2009-2012
Dave Meier	2	1984-1985
Alex Ochoa	1	1998-1998
Andy Kosco	3	1965-1967
Terry Tiffee	3	2004-2006
Jesus Vega	3	1979-1982
Mike Lamb	1	2008-2008
Terry Jorgensen	3	1989-1993
Tsuyoshi Nishioka	2	2011-2012
Fred Manrique	1	1990-1990
Jackie Hernandez	2	1967-1968
Midre Cummings	2	1999-2000
Greg Colbrunn	1	1997-1997
Butch Huskey	1	2000-2000
Ray Smith	3	1981-1983
Brent Brede	2	1996-1997
Bill Butler	3	1974-1977
Scott Aldred	2	1996-1997
Dan Masteller	1	1995-1995
Billy Beane	2	1986-1987
Jeff Reed	3	1984-1986
Matt Merullo	1	1995-1995
Steve Luebber	3	1971-1976
Nelson Liriano	1	1990-1990
Mike Stenhouse	1	1985-1985
Jason Maxwell	2	2000-2001
Tony Batista	1	2006-2006
George Banks	3	1962-1964
Chris Gomez	1	2003-2003
Hal Naragon	2	1961-1962
Jose Offerman	1	2004-2004
Rene Tosoni	1	2011-2011
Joe Nossek	3	1964-1966
Alex Burnett	3	2010-2012
Eddie Bane	3	1973-1976
Tom Nieto	2	1987-1988
Paul Hartzell	1	1979-1979
Craig Monroe	1	2008-2008
Darin Mastroianni	1	2012-2012
Danny Walton	2	1973-1975
Jose Morales	3	2007-2010
Billy Gardner	1	1961-1961
Jeff Cirillo	1	2007-2007
Jose Valdivielso	1	1961-1961
Shane Rawley	1	1989-1989
Livan Hernandez	1	2008-2008
Marcus Jensen	1	2000-2000
Jim Eisenreich	3	1982-1984
Sergio Ferrer	2	1974-1975
Terry Felton	4	1979-1982
Chris Latham	3	1997-1999
Pedro Florimon	1	2012-2012
Jose Parra	2	1995-1996
Dan Monzon	2	1972-1973
Darrin Jackson	1	1997-1997
Chad Moeller	1	2000-2000
Adam Everett	1	2008-2008
Tom Kelly	1	1975-1975
Dan Dobbek	1	1961-1961
Bruce Look	1	1968-1968
Bob Gorinski	1	1977-1977
Tom Tischinski	3	1969-1971
Derek Parks	3	1992-1994
Michael Restovich	3	2002-2004
Ted Lepcio	1	1961-1961
Carlos Pulido	3	1994-2004
Dan Naulty	3	1996-1998
Jerald Clark	1	1995-1995
Joe Niekro	2	1987-1988
Matt Kinney	2	2000-2002
Liam Hendriks	2	2011-2012
Tim Drummond	2	1989-1990
Dan Serafini	3	1996-1998
Reno Bertoia	1	1961-1961
Rene Rivera	1	2011-2011
Jack Cressend	3	2000-2002
Ed Hodge	1	1984-1984
Rusty Kuntz	1	1983-1983
Todd Ritchie	2	1997-1998
Alvaro Espinoza	3	1984-1986
Larry Milbourne	1	1982-1982
Mike Lincoln	2	1999-2000
J.T. Bruett	2	1992-1993
Joe Altobelli	1	1961-1961
Paul Abbott	3	1990-1992
Ramon Ortiz	1	2007-2007
Jeff Holly	3	1977-1979
Mike Bacsik	2	1979-1980
Mike Walters	2	1983-1984
Benj Sampson	2	1998-1999
Randy Hundley	1	1974-1974
Dan Perkins	1	1999-1999
Cole De Vries	1	2012-2012
Doug Baker	3	1988-1990
Jim Snyder	3	1961-1964
Mark Funderburk	2	1981-1985
Dave Johnson	2	1977-1978
Jeff Manship	4	2009-2012
Julio Becquer	2	1961-1963
Garry Roggenburk	3	1963-1966
Chris Heintz	3	2005-2007
Mike Hartley	1	1993-1993
Mike Durant	1	1996-1996
Josh Rabe	2	2006-2007
Scott Ullger	1	1983-1983
Sam Deduno	1	2012-2012
Todd Sears	2	2002-2003
Garrett Jones	1	2007-2007
Scott Klingenbeck	2	1995-1996
Greg Hansell	1	1996-1996
Georges Maranda	1	1962-1962
Bernardo Brito	3	1992-1995
Brian Dinkelman	1	2011-2011
Jim Strickland	3	1971-1973
Mike Adams	2	1972-1973
Mike Dyer	1	1989-1989
Joe Benson	1	2011-2011
Joe Roa	1	2004-2004
Don Cooper	2	1981-1982
Ron Henry	2	1961-1964
Sean Bergman	1	2000-2000
Grant Balfour	3	2001-2004
Brian Bass	1	2008-2008
George Tsamis	1	1993-1993
Jay Ryan	2	1999-2000
Ted Sadowski	2	1961-1962
Brent Abernathy	1	2005-2005
Rick Dempsey	4	1969-1972
Damian Miller	1	1997-1997
Chuck Baker	1	1981-1981
Matt Carson	1	2012-2012
R.A. Dickey	1	2009-2009
Pat Bourque	1	1974-1974
Quinton McCracken	1	2001-2001
Randy Ruiz	1	2008-2008
Frank Eufemia	1	1985-1985
P.J. Walters	1	2012-2012
Erik Schullstrom	2	1994-1995
Pete Hamm	2	1970-1971
Augie Ojeda	1	2004-2004
Willie Eyre	1	2006-2006
Roy Lee Jackson	1	1986-1986
Casey Blake	3	2000-2002
John Barnes	2	2000-2001
Stan Perzanowski	1	1978-1978
Jerry Fosnow	2	1964-1965
Kevin Maas	1	1995-1995
Francisco Oliveras	1	1989-1989
Danny Fife	2	1973-1974
Mel Nelson	2	1965-1967
Bobby Keppel	1	2009-2009
Dan Schatzeder	2	1987-1988
Greg Wells	1	1982-1982
Craig Breslow	2	2008-2009
Andre David	2	1984-1986
Curt Wardle	2	1984-1985
Steve Carlton	2	1987-1988
Bret Boone	1	2005-2005
John Pacella	1	1982-1982
Jarvis Brown	2	1991-1992
Jeff Gray	1	2012-2012
Donnie Hill	1	1992-1992
Seth Greisinger	1	2004-2004
Tim Corcoran	1	1981-1981
Paul Boris	1	1982-1982
German Gonzalez	2	1988-1989
Aaron Fultz	1	2004-2004
Al Schroll	1	1961-1961
Frank Pastore	1	1986-1986
Joe Grzenda	1	1969-1969
Hal Haydel	2	1970-1971
Mike Pazik	3	1975-1977
Wally Post	1	1963-1963
Jay Ward	2	1963-1964
Greg Thayer	1	1978-1978
Jim Ollom	2	1966-1967
Chuck Stobbs	1	1961-1961
John Sutton	1	1978-1978
Frank Sullivan	2	1962-1963
Ken Sanders	1	1973-1973
Vic Wertz	1	1963-1963
Brett Merriman	2	1993-1994
Eduardo Escobar	1	2012-2012
Ron Mahay	2	2009-2010
Alex Prieto	2	2003-2004
Greg Johnston	2	1980-1981
Pat Borders	1	2004-2004
Phil Nevin	1	2006-2006
Steve Dunn	2	1994-1995
Phil Dumatrait	1	2011-2011
Glenn Williams	1	2005-2005
Jon Shave	1	1998-1998
Bob Kipper	1	1992-1992
Steve Barber	2	1970-1971
Mark Wiley	1	1975-1975
Bob Gebhard	2	1971-1972
Larry Pashnick	1	1984-1984
John Christensen	1	1988-1988
Orlando Mercado	1	1989-1989
Pat Putnam	1	1984-1984
Sidney Ponson	1	2007-2007
Mike Poepping	1	1975-1975
Rob Bowen	2	2003-2004
Jeff Little	1	1982-1982
Pat Kelly	2	1967-1968
Oscar Munoz	1	1995-1995
Casey Fien	1	2012-2012
Kevin Campbell	2	1994-1995
Matt Macri	1	2008-2008
Bryan Oelkers	1	1983-1983
Jason Marquis	1	2012-2012
Greg Harris	1	1995-1995
Chris Speier	1	1984-1984
Darren Reed	1	1992-1992
Chris Pittaro	2	1986-1987
Derek Lee	1	1993-1993
Tom Norton	1	1972-1972
Luis Ayala	1	2009-2009
Mac Scarce	1	1978-1978
Danny Ardoin	1	2000-2000
Bud Bulling	1	1977-1977
Elmer Valo	1	1961-1961
Erik Komatsu	1	2012-2012
Kyle Waldrop	2	2011-2012
Paul Powell	1	1971-1971
Esmerling Vasquez	1	2012-2012
George Thomas	1	1971-1971
Dennis Burtt	2	1985-1986
Bill Bethea	1	1964-1964
Jerry Crider	1	1969-1969
Mike Hart	1	1984-1984
Al Woods	1	1986-1986
Tommy Watkins	1	2007-2007
Ruben Sierra	1	2006-2006
Tom Lundstedt	1	1975-1975
Clete Thomas	1	2012-2012
Danny McDevitt	1	1961-1961
Bob Veselic	2	1980-1981
Wilson Ramos	1	2010-2010
Travis Baptist	1	1998-1998
Jay Pettibone	1	1983-1983
Greg Brummett	1	1993-1993
Erik Bennett	1	1996-1996
Hank Izquierdo	1	1967-1967
Jack Savage	1	1990-1990
Adam Johnson	2	2001-2003
Mike Kinnunen	1	1980-1980
Tyler Robertson	1	2012-2012
Sam Perlozzo	1	1977-1977
Brad Thomas	3	2001-2004
Herman Hill	2	1969-1970
Jim Hoey	1	2011-2011
Mike Fornieles	1	1963-1963
Joe Klink	1	1987-1987
Brian Raabe	2	1995-1996
Scott Watkins	1	1995-1995
Randy St. Claire	1	1989-1989
Mike Milchin	1	1996-1996
Cleatus Davidson	1	1999-1999
Ron Keller	2	1966-1968
Carmen Cali	1	2007-2007
Mike Cook	1	1989-1989
Jim Winn	1	1988-1988
Bert Cueto	1	1961-1961
Ed Palmquist	1	1961-1961
Denny Neagle	1	1991-1991
Philip Humber	2	2008-2009
Julio DePaula	1	2007-2007
Juan Agosto	1	1986-1986
Todd Jones	1	2001-2001
Mo Sanford	1	1995-1995
Ruben Gomez	1	1962-1962
Steve Howe	1	1985-1985
Shane Bowers	1	1997-1997
Paul Giel	1	1961-1961
Joe McCabe	1	1964-1964
Randy Bass	1	1977-1977
Bobby Korecky	1	2008-2008
Garland Shifflett	1	1964-1964
Jim Lewis	1	1983-1983
Marty Martinez	1	1962-1962
Chris Herrmann	1	2012-2012
Eric Bullock	1	1988-1988
Steve Shields	1	1989-1989
Steve Holm	1	2011-2011
Sean Burroughs	1	2012-2012
Luis Perdomo	1	2012-2012
Walt Bond	1	1967-1967
Danny Morris	2	1968-1969
Kelvin Torve	1	1988-1988
Mark Brown	1	1985-1985
Bill Latham	1	1986-1986
Ray Fontenot	1	1986-1986
Minnie Mendoza	1	1970-1970
Alejandro Sanchez	1	1986-1986
John Sevcik	1	1965-1965
James Baldwin	1	2003-2003
Jackie Collum	1	1962-1962
Lester Oliveros	2	2011-2012
Don Carrithers	1	1977-1977
Ken Brett	1	1979-1979
Cotton Nash	2	1969-1970
Mike Nakamura	1	2003-2003
Kevin Jarvis	1	1997-1997
Gary Dotter	3	1961-1964
Lee Tunnell	1	1989-1989
Karl Best	1	1988-1988
Mike Maksudian	1	1993-1993
Roric Harrison	1	1978-1978
Kevin Frederick	1	2002-2002
Corky Miller	1	2005-2005
Dusty Hughes	1	2011-2011
Vic Rodriguez	1	1989-1989
Fred Lasher	1	1963-1963
Buzz Stephen	1	1968-1968
Sean Henn	1	2009-2009
Matt Maloney	1	2012-2012
Rich Garces	2	1990-1993
Travis Bowyer	1	2005-2005
Jim Donohue	1	1962-1962
Darnell McDonald	1	2007-2007
David Lamb	1	2002-2002
Brian Fuentes	1	2010-2010
Chuck James	1	2011-2011
Greg Booker	1	1989-1989
Vince Horsman	1	1995-1995
Tom Klawitter	1	1985-1985
Keith Garagozzo	1	1994-1994
Rob Radlosky	1	1999-1999
Carroll Hardy	1	1967-1967
Howie Clark	1	2008-2008
Jeff Bittiger	1	1987-1987
Dave Gassner	1	2005-2005
Jake Jacobs	1	1961-1961
Gregg Olson	1	1997-1997
Riccardo Ingram	1	1995-1995
Jim Manning	1	1962-1962
Charlie Walters	1	1969-1969
J.D. Durbin	1	2004-2004
Bill Fischer	1	1964-1964
Mike Mason	1	1988-1988
Bud Bloomfield	1	1964-1964
Dwight Lowry	1	1988-1988
Warren Morris	1	2002-2002
Anthony Slama	2	2010-2011
Mike Fetters	1	2003-2003
John Hobbs	1	1981-1981
Jim Shellenback	1	1977-1977
Keith Comstock	1	1984-1984
Bill Whitby	1	1964-1964
Pete Whisenant	1	1961-1961
Tom Quinlan	1	1996-1996
Matt Fox	1	2010-2010
Rich Yett	2	1985-1990
Danny Mota	1	2000-2000
Mike Duvall	1	2001-2001
Randy Niemann	1	1987-1987
Gary Rath	1	1999-1999
Luis Quinones	1	1992-1992
Billy Consolo	1	1961-1961
Eric Hacker	1	2011-2011
Tack Wilson	1	1983-1983
Sal Campisi	1	1971-1971
Jesse Orosco	1	2003-2003
Don Williams	1	1963-1963
Jose Rodriguez	1	2002-2002
Jason Miller	1	2007-2007
Tippy Martinez	1	1988-1988
Jason Pridie	2	2008-2009
Dan Graham	1	1979-1979
Randy Flores	1	2010-2010
Bucky Brandon	1	1969-1969
Kevin Stanfield	1	1979-1979
Mike Smith	1	2006-2006
Armando Gabino	1	2009-2009
Bucky Guth	1	1972-1972
Greg Olson	1	1989-1989
Justin Huber	1	2009-2009
Chuck Nieson	1	1964-1964
Juan Morillo	1	2009-2009
Mauro Gozzo	1	1992-1992
Joe Beimel	1	2004-2004
Kevin Mulvey	1	2009-2009
Ryan Jorgensen	1	2008-2008
Rob Delaney	1	2010-2010
Fred Bruckbauer	1	1961-1961

AMR says:

October 12, 2012 at 1:15 pm

It's gonna take a long time to get #192 off that list.
1. Nate Tubbs Rules says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 3:06 pm
  
  Yeah, I know Brendan has a pretty ugly looking line, but he was a pretty useful player on the 2008 team that came within a whisper of the postseason (I know the popular storyline is to bring up the 1-0 loss to Thome, but the killer was losing 2 of 3 to KC the last weekend while it seemed Morneau could do nothing but strikeout or DP with guys on base)
Rhubarb_Runner says:

October 12, 2012 at 1:37 pm

might want to separate the column headings "ERA+/OPS+" and "ERA/AVG" so it word wraps to two lines; my table is off the right side currently.
1. Rhubarb_Runner says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 3:41 pm
  
  muchos bester, grassy ass
spookymilk says:

October 12, 2012 at 1:41 pm

Nate, I'm super psyched that you came back this year to post this (I don't remember if you showed up after last season, but at any rate, it's been too long). Thanks for taking the time to do this impossible task.

Edit: This previously said "NBB." Nate and New Britain Bo are not the same person. I am always aware of this, but when the time comes for acronyms, my thoughts scatter.
1. Nate Tubbs Rules says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 3:08 pm
  
  I was here a little bit last season, but I never tried to post my updates to top300 (I had always relied on SBG to post on his old site). Glad to be back and stop lurking. If we keep improving by 3 wins every year we'll have the postseason back within a decade.....
  1. meat says:
    
    October 12, 2012 at 3:45 pm
    
    If we keep improving by 3 wins every year we'll have the postseason back within a decade.....
    
    Ouch.
2. New Britain Bo says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 7:04 pm
  
  TonyO not in #2 spot - I cry.
  1. New Britain Bo says:
    
    October 12, 2012 at 7:09 pm
    
    But preciate the list nonetheless. Spot on, pally.
The Dread Pirate says:

October 12, 2012 at 3:12 pm

Mark Redman above Scott Diamond? Not criticizing, but I'm curious. Glad to have you back; your list is always a great conversation-starter.
1. Nate Tubbs Rules says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 3:25 pm
  
  Diamond's 2012 sure looks a lot like Redman's 2000. Both on terrible teams, Redman 12-9 with a 109 ERA+ and Diamond 12-9 with a 115 ERA+. Diamond pitched about 20 more innings in his big year but they were about the same amount of innings overall (since Redman pitched for a while before being traded in 2001) and the ERA+ and WAR numbers are pretty similar.
  1. DK says:
    
    October 12, 2012 at 3:33 pm
    
    The offensive environment of the Redman Era was a lot different than that of the Diamond Era.
    1. Rhubarb_Runner says:
      
      October 12, 2012 at 3:43 pm
      
      Not sure which meaning you meant for "offensive" but I decided it didn't matter
    2. The Dread Pirate says:
      
      October 12, 2012 at 4:47 pm
      
      True, DK. Plus, IIRC Redman was the "original" Twin for the current crop: he complained about being hurt and the team thought he was a giant wuss and kept complaining about him not wanting to pitch throughout 2001.
sean says:

October 12, 2012 at 3:24 pm

I reformatted it to use my sports-reference plugin. Now it also fits on the page and is sortable.
1. meat says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 3:50 pm
  
  Hrm... If I select rank after another sortable category the table gives me some screwy results including Denny's Sampler Platter as the number one twin of all time.
  1. sean says:
    
    October 12, 2012 at 4:12 pm
    
    The 'Rk' column is special. It will always display the current order based on the column you're ordering. If you sort something and then choose the Rk column, it will effectively reverse the list.
    1. meat says:
      
      October 12, 2012 at 4:15 pm
      
      Well, I'm not surprised that I didn't know that.
      1. sean says:
        
        October 12, 2012 at 4:34 pm
        
        I think the population of people who didn't know that was everyone but me.
        
        brianS says:
        
        October 13, 2012 at 12:29 am
        
        so, this really needs a "NTR rank" column so that one can re-sort back to the original order (without having to re-load the page).
        
        Wow. Mauer already 5th on the franchise WAR list. Johan stuck at 10th for the foreseeable future. I have a hard time imagining Mountie, Baker or Dspan sticking around the franchise long and productively enough to move into the top 10.
        
        So, who will the next top-ten entrant be? That player probably isn't even with the organization yet.
        
        sean says:
        
        October 13, 2012 at 11:16 am
        
        Not true. Unsorting the column will return it to its original state. I considered having another column for the NTR rank for when you were sorting, but decided against it because it would have taken a bit of work to re-do things.
Rhubarb_Runner says:

October 12, 2012 at 3:47 pm

a couple more things which might be nice on this table: a '*' or something indicating Twins HOF, and last year's rank (just curious)
1. Nate Tubbs Rules says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 4:41 pm
  
  movement is tougher to track with some ups and downs. Mauer stayed put in 2011, but passed up Hrbek this year moving up 1 spot. Morneau has stayed put for 2 years. Nathan didn't move from 2010 to 2011. Cuddy moved up 9 spots last year. Kubel moved up 4 spots after 2011. Baker moved up 16 spots after 2011 (and then back 1 when Span passed him this year). Span moved up 15 spots in the last 2 years, Liriano moved up 5 spots in 2011 and stayed put in 2012. Pavano was outside the top100 and moved up about 10 spots in 2011 and then back 1 spot due to Willingham passing him in 2011. Thome moved up 35 spots after 2011. Blackburn moved up 6 spots in 2011 and then back 3 spots in 2012. Duensing moved up 21 spots in 2011 and then back 1 in 2012. Slowey lost 10 spots in 2011. Valencia moved up 28 spots in 2011 and then back 3 in 2012. Perkins moved up 27 spots in 2011 and another 19 spots in 2012. Casilla went up 30 spots in 2011 and back 3 in 2012.
meat says:

October 12, 2012 at 5:09 pm

I'll point out that, for the time being, ma boy 'Lexi is valued higher than the Diamond in the rough. Suck it Greekhouse.
1. AMR says:
  
  October 12, 2012 at 7:57 pm
  
  All that despite a .150 OBP!

Comments are closed.

WGOM

One man’s opinion of the top300 Twins ever

27 thoughts on “One man’s opinion of the top300 Twins ever”

Remodeled basement. Same half-baked taste.