So after some discussion we decided that we do not want the same players on the ballot indefinitely, even if they don't fall below 25%. Here are the reasons:
1. Some players likely will not change much. For example, it appears about 35% of voters feel that Comiskey deserves to go in because of what he did outside of his playing days. This will likely stay rather static.
2. For players close to the 75% threshold, the pressure of falling off the ballot will likely generate more discussion.
3. We felt it will be more fun if players are judged against their contemporaries.
Therefore, the MAXIMUM number of times a player can be on the ballot is SIX. This is ballot number five. When it's a player's last turn on the ballot, it will be made clear.
Three years per ballot isn't standard, but so far it's how things are falling. 1903-1905 only has seven eligible players, so there may be more years on the next ballot if we have the regular amount of people fall off.
Due Date: July 7. I'm going on my honeymoon on July 11, so I hope to post results on July 10.
Continue reading WGOM Half-Baked Hall: 1900-1902 →