Friday Fungoes: Hot Corner Hypothetical

When I first encountered this question, it was posited slightly different than how I'm ultimately going to present it to you. Here's the original question: As general manager of a hypothetical team, you are left to determine who your team will be better of with manning third base - Harmon Killebrew or Brooks Robinson. Thanks to hypothetical suspension of free agency, you get either player for his entire career. There's no question Killebrew was the better hitter, and likewise no question that Robinson was the superior defender. Who do you choose?

I wanted to update the players in this question a little bit, so my modification is this - would your team be better with Chipper Jones or Scott Rolen at third base? Continue reading Friday Fungoes: Hot Corner Hypothetical

Happy Birthday–March 2

Horace Fogel (1861)
Moe Berg (1902)
Woody English (1906)
Jack Knott (1907)
Mel Ott (1909)
Mort Cooper (1913)
Jim Konstanty (1917)
Jim Nettles (1947)
Pete Broberg (1950)
Larry Wolfe (1953)
Terry Steinbach (1962)
Ron Gant (1965)
Jay Gibbons (1977)
Glen Perkins (1983)

Horace Fogel was a sportswriter who became manager of the New York Giants in 1902.  His time as Giants manager is best remembered for his attempt to move Christy Mathewson to first base.  He was fired 41 games into the season and replaced by Heinie Smith, who put an end to such nonsense.  Instead, he tried to move Mathewson to shortstop. 

Continue reading Happy Birthday–March 2

Classic Album Reviews: Some Girls — Rolling Stones (1978)

As the last great Rolling Stones album, Some Girls came out at a time of enormous flux in popular music. In 1978, disco was still hugely popular and of course all the cool kids knew about punk.  A lot of the rock giants from the 60’s were either burnt out, gone, or easing into the nostalgia circuit. But not the Stones, they delivered one of their finest albums, one that covered disco, punk, and of course straight ahead rock and rock. There is/was only one band that could pull off such an effort and make it work, and for that reason deserves to be considered a classic album worthy of review at the WGOM.

One reason I really like Some Girls is that it not only reflects the times in which it was made but also reflects where the Rolling Stones were as a band and as individuals. By 1978 the Rolling Stones were nearly a decade into their “Greatest Rock and Roll Band” persona, with all the money, groupies, drugs, and adulation that goes with it. Jetting off to Rio, St. Moritz, or New York, was a monthly occurrence and the Stones obliged by having houses, girlfriends, and parties at all the world’s hot spots, always ready to hit the scene with other beautiful people.

Thankfully the Rolling Stones music didn’t suffer with all this jet setting, in fact, at the time of Some Girls’ recording, Keith Richards was cleaner – drug wise – than he had been for years. The recording sessions were in Paris and by all accounts were extremely productive. In fact the song Start Me Up was first recorded for Some Girls but Keith argued against its inclusion because he thought he stole the riff (turns out it was his own riff he stole). Just think how great this album would have been if it had also included Start Me Up?!! Wowza!

The album crosses many musical genres with the Stones putting their signature on Disco (Miss You), Country (Far Away Eyes), Motown (Imagination), and Punk (Shattered). The rest are straight ahead rock and rollers with the song Respectable an overlooked classic that should be dissected and taught in Rock School. The album ends with the song Shattered which perfectly described New York City circa 1978. The album got a lot of radio play and I purchased it shortly after it was released (with the Farrah Fawcett and Lucille Ball images on the cover -- since changed due to lawsuits) and hungrily lapped it up in all its rock and roll glory. Besides the songs listed above, Keith Richards’ Before They Make Me Run and Beast of Burden were favorites. It was the perfect Rolling Stones album with a solid rhythm section, Keith’s fantastic riffs, and Mick’s vocals unmatched before or since.

The album ended up being one of the Rolling Stones biggest selling albums and for better or worse resurrected their career and ensured that they would be recording and releasing albums of new material well into the next millennium. While not considered as strong as some Stones classics like Sticky Fingers, Beggars Banquet, or Exile on Main Street, I would argue that Some Girls is a fantastic rock album and somewhat slightly forgotten about over the years.  If you haven’t listened to it for a while, I strongly encourage you to give it a spin.

Berserk Boxscores: Tigers @ Twins 5/18/1969

Billy Martin was a below average but serviceable infielder for the Yankees while they won four world series in the 50's.  He was traded during his age 29 season and bounced around to several teams, never staying anywhere longer than a year. His final year at age 33 was with the brand new Minnesota Twins.  In 108 games he played poorly and retired after the season.  Still young, he got hired as a scout for the Twins, then was promoted to coach.  In 1968 he got his first chance at being manager, leading the Twins affiliate Denver Bears at the end of their season.  In 1969, he replaced Cal Ermer as the manager for the big club.  It didn't take long for Billy to get a reputation as a manager with a cunning mind, even if he didn't always make the best decisions.  One of the first things he did as manager was tell Rod Carew to steal whenever and wherever he damned well please.

Carew obeyed.  On May 18th, the Twins were in 2nd place and had lost three consecutive games and facing a pretty good Tigers team.  Mickey Lolich was starting for the Tigers, Dave Boswell for the Twins.  Entering the bottom of the 3rd, the Twins were down 2-0.  Cesar Tovar singled, then moved to second on a balk.  Tovar promptly stole third before Rod Carew drew a walk.  Now, Harmon Killebrew was up with nobody out.  The double steal was pulled off, though I was unable to tell if it was a straight steal of home or if the throw went down to second first.  Either way, a double steal happened with Killebrew at the plate at nobody out.

Now, Carew is on second base.  Restless, he stole third base.  Now, Carew is on third base with Harmon Killebrew at the plate.  And there is still NOBODY OUT.  What's the logical thing to do?  Steal home!  Carew did so and the Twins tied the game.  Killebrew would strike out, and the Twins wouldn't score the rest of the game.  No word if Lolich whined about Carew not playing the game the right way.

Carew stole home seven times during the 69 season, twice with Killebrew at the plate.  The other time was with two outs, but Killebrew said that neither time did he know Carew was coming home.  This prompted a staff person with the Twins to write Carew's epitaph:

Here lies Rod Carew, lined to left by Killebrew.

The Twins would go on to win the division, losing to an amazing Orioles team in the brand new ALCS.  Billy Martin would punch out Dave Boswell in the parking lot and lose his job with the Twins at the end of the year.  And Rod Carew stopped stealing home so much.